Upside down stars on Republican logo

6 posts / 0 new
Last post
Jgmdesign
Jgmdesign's picture

Thom,

As a designer who's created many logos, it looks to me like they flipped the stars in order to make them larger and stil fit inside the elephant..  If you flip them right side up, the points will stick out of the elephant, so you would have to make them smaller to fit, which doesn't have the same graphic impact.  That, and following Beelzebub's explicit orders of course...... : )

Comments

Jgmdesign
Jgmdesign's picture
Thom, you're still saying

Thom, you're still saying nobody knows.....

Bush_Wacker
Bush_Wacker's picture
That makes sense.  I mean,

That makes sense.  I mean, making the elephant a little bigger or the stars a little smaller was probably unimaginable.

Pierpont
Pierpont's picture
Jgmdesign wrote:If you flip

Jgmdesign wrote:
If you flip them right side up, the points will stick out of the elephant, so you would have to make them smaller to fit, which doesn't have the same graphic impact. 
While there may be some design consideration involved, your explanation makes NO sense. A star's points will fit in a circle. The stars could just have well be face up and still fit just fine.. and if they didn't, they could just raise the elephant's back a bit. There are different versions showing this could easily be done.

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-h3WLnpWEF-I/Twz0qoikLoI/AAAAAAAACAo/Ld08H_TTeH0/s1600/GOP.jpg

http://www.bafractals.com/DOG_BLOG_DIR/wp-content/uploads/2008/12/hi_res_elephant1.bmp 

harry ashburn
harry ashburn's picture
i heard a republican explain

i heard a republican explain that the designers of the logo originally had the elephant shown as "rampant" i.e. on his hind legs.  at that angle, they made the stars up-right.   then they put the elephant back on all fours, but "neglected"?  to re adjust the stars.

Karolina
Karolina's picture
You do not change a key

You do not change a key element in a graphic logo, unless either you are a careless designer and the client doesn't care, OR you were asked to make the change by your client, who has a point that he/she wants to make by this change.