Recent comments

  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    I think that Obama and all Americans should revisit the story of Emitt Till.
    Photos matter, and the lame excuse Obama gives is just that. Inflaming hatred for America?

    I think that happens more when we use drones to bomb babies than when we prosecute fellow americans for war crimes.

    I think it speaks to the ethnocentric ism that dominates our country, that the President doesnt think Afghanis or Muslims are capable of understanding the difference between an endorsement of torture(i.e not prosecuting criminals) and accountability for said criminals.

    Wont it look worse when it becomes glaringly apparent to the ppl we are supposed to fear, that they are held to a different standard than that which we hold ourselves too??

    I think it does far more to "inflame: hatred of America by not prosecuting .

    Maybe I am Crazy......

  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Could somebody please post the website that has the pictures that Thom has been talking about today?

  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    FLASHBACK July 29, 2008 ..... Pelosi Claims No Bush Crime, No Cause for Impeachment

  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    I wrote this message to Barack Obama through the ACLU website.

    Showing these photos might or might not inflame the Islamic world,
    depending on the way it is portrayed. If we show how much we deplore
    this kind of thing the rest of the world, which already knows what
    has happened and has taken steps to bring the architects of this
    new holocaust to justice.
    No single man can change the laws to protect himself from committing a crime. We cannot stand by and allow committing murder to become ok by anyone.
    We should not only investigate crimes, but find out what kind of sick deseased mind could think up such sadistic acts.

  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Tom is speak from another age when he gives samples of Japan and Lt Calley. In this new time youth have been exposed to horrors on TV and internet, so showing executions will not get the response he expects.

    And, as too many have forgotten; Obama said on more than one occasion that he cannot do what needs to be done without our help (every one of us). If we sit on our hands and do not call, protest, write and fax our representatives in DC then we will not get the results that Obama told that we can get. So, we does our campaign to stop the madness.

  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Tzedik. Tzedik. Tzedik . . . Justice. Justice. Justice you shall seek.

    “Sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants.” Justice Louis D. Brandeis

    Torture is America’s newest ugly child. Arthur Miller, in After the Fall, describes the situation exactly. We must face brutal horror, examine it, kiss it full upon the mouth and own that it is us . . . before we can get through this.

    Anything else lacks humanity and violates humanity beyond its core.

  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Thom, Last week you read my comment on air, and said that I was the winner. What did I win?

  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Our country engaged in torture and now we know about it. We must demand that the torturers be brought to justice. Not only those who ordered it but those who actually did it. Because we know it was done, failure to prosecute those
    responsible makes us accomplices after the fact. We can not even
    claim, as the Germans did, that we did not know. We do know! Crimes
    were committed in our name. Crimes against Humanity. I am sickened
    that anyone can defend what was done. If there are any moral or
    ethical absolutes, surely one of them is the requirement that people
    (or animals for that matter) under our control, unable to defend
    themselves, must not be mistreated.

    After World War II we declared to the world that torture was so
    abhorrent, so far outside the bounds of acceptable human behavior that
    it's perpetrators needed to be prosecuted and, if found guilty,
    executed. And we did so. Even though, as far as I know, there was no
    specific law making it illegal.


  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Torture is immoral and should be illegal, whether it works or not.

    If I were ever in the extremely unlikely "ticking time bomb" scenario like in the tv show "24", I would probably torture someone for information but I would then expect to go to jail for it. I would never expect that behavior to be socially acceptable or legal.

  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Morning class-

    I see the conservatives still trying to learn how to use a computer are here. I believe President Obama is fearing for his life here or at least being told what to do by the military industrial complex. we must keep visualizing that candle of hope and continue to demand a free and open society. G-d bless the ACLU- send them some money.

    Here is my diagnostic to the right. If the right wingers support not showing the pictures, then this destroys your argument that being big bad butch torturers will protect us. The military does not support torture for this reason being they have their own best interests in mind.

    It is so fundamental, you hurt someone, they hurt you back, then their relatives hurt your relatives and wa la- you have perpetual war. Jesus was the bigger man and taught us to turn the other cheek in love, knowing this would end the ways of war.

  • May 14th 2009 Thursday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Hey, B-tRoll -

    Thom HATES America??!!! Nice try, dude. I guess, however, that your post puts the concept that registration keeps the trolls out in a poor light.

    If you listen to Thom's show AT ALL, then you've heard his arguement re:card check and the Employee Free Choice Act, but I'll take the trouble to restare it here - IF YOU WANT TO PARTICIPATE IN A PUBLIC, DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTION, YOU MUST STATE YOUR INTENTION TO DO SO, PUBLICLY. You wanna vote? You go to a public building and register. You want to have a union in your work place? Sign a card that says so. You want to participate in the discussions in this forum? Tell the moderators who you are.

    On the other hand, if you don't want anyone here to know anything about you, you are welcome to keep your opinions to yourself.

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Jeff in Denver,

    I remembered the same info. regarding Rumsfeld and his connection with Gilead. What do they say --- the simplest answer is often the truth?!

  • May 12th 2009 Tuesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    I too, find the "Economic Meltdown" peculiar but the timing, as Thom has pointed out, was not exactly as it was planned. The meltdown was not supposed to have started until Bush was out of office but in true "Bush" fashion he couldn't get that right either.

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    THOM, I DISAGREE!!! (from former Marine officer, honorable discharge 1969)
    I have the highest respect for your mission, your clear thinking and good research, but for you to not take the time to clarify your statement, "they don't want us to trust government" so they can make the money is at best incomplete and at worst playing into "their" hands. I mean just now in one breath, after saying this several times, you used governmental officials as examples of the worst crimes! I'll give a shot at a better way to say it and then explain why it is a significant rephrasing:
    "They don't want us to trust the potential of the public's ability to maintain a government that is by the people and for the people." And continue, "Instead, they want to control government themselves while trying to dismantel any populist laws that exist in government. And one way for them to keep us from protesting is to make it seem they are against government."
    NOW, here is why it is important. Although as a former Viet Nam era Marine, I do understand Obama's decision to protect the troops by not showing photos, but he is wrong because the enemy knows already how ugly it is, The folks who don't really know are the people in the U.S. who might just get made enough to demand accountability for the Bush criminals. Now, consider your own position on this, and your commentes just now made about the apparent suicide of the waterboarded "witness" responsble for connecting 9/11 to the Taliban, etc. And then consider your reluctance to even TALK about the evidence surrounding Paul Wellstone's assassination (I wrote the book) or the amazing data in support of Cheney being behinid 9/11 (I am co author of the Elseveir text on this). Are these positions because you, like Noam, Amy, and so many others on the left "WANT TO MAKE SURE WE TRUST THE GOVERNMENT?" I hope you see my point my friend. In any case, keep up the good work. The fear of "conspiracy theory" does not lessen my admiration for what you are doing.But until we can wake up from the HEGEMONY that prevents us realizing the worse then working toward the best will continue.
    Whooa, just now you respond to a call about the influence of corporations on government and I agree that we need to be active in government, but we can't DO this if we are not willing to understand that we cannot trust government WHEN it is controlled by corporations. So stay with that concept and please reconsider the value of talking about 9/11 and Wellstone. And while you are at it, talk about General Smedley Butler, the most decorated U.S. Marine and why no one talks about him either.
    Four Arrows
    Author, American Assassination

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    They aren't THE aristocracy, they're the aristocracy's puppets.

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    In regard to credit card companies, people who lose their jobs and miss a payment or two have more problems than they think, Once late and over-limit fees kick-in, there's no stopping the spiral of debt unless you take on the companies yourself, and that only after a period of time battling them. You could go into bankruptcy (not the best option) or go to a law firm that will charge you thousands of dollars in fees to eventually reduce your debt, or pay one of these so-called "credit counseling services"--actually collection agencies for the credit card companies--do what you could have done yourself: get deeper into debt while the credit companies haggle over payment plans. The only thing that seems to work is threatening not to pay anything at all unless they stop charging over-limit and late fees, and reduce the finance charges. Of course, you have to keep on them month after month, until they've decided that they've piled on so much debt through those additional charges that even they might think that they've beat on you long enough.

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Thom you are asking for what to call republicans and I want to bring back a word to describe them and this/their wall st. class...


    Please spread this word around, it is a great grassroots first step to helping take back America for us, the peasants

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    CNBC is reporting that William Seidman has died at age 88.

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    My favorite rename for the GOP comes from Bob Kincaid of the Head On Radio Network ( when he refers to them as the "Repiglican Party".

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    One caller mentioned earlier that both parties are owned by the rich. This is something I hear pretty often from conservatives and I think it is a fair thing to say. However I would like to draw a distinction. Within in the conservative movement, taking money in the form of campaign contributions in exchange of favorable legislation is how the system is supposed to work. As far as conservatives are concerned transnational corporations are just concerned citizens and giving huge donations to public officials is just their way of exercising their constitutionally protected freedom of speech. On the other hand though, within the progressive movement, the same phenomenon is called corruption and ideally it is behavior that should be eliminated, not propagated.

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    Often during the years of the Bush takeover, when the cabal was getting too much attention for its illegal deeds some scary thing would suddenly rise up to distract the country. Some of the scares came in the form of raising the terrorism alert level, anthrax scares, and the bird flu warnings.

    Torture and Tamiflu

    Now the heat is turned way up on Cheney/Bush and company and their role in torture.

    So gee, what happens? Another flu scare that came at a convenient time and seemed fishy from the get go.

    And where does it appear that the flu came from? The company that makes Tamiflu, Gilead.

    And who is connected to Tamiflu? Torture leader - Donald Rumsfeld, who was Chairman of the Board and owns millions of stock in Gilead, as do other Cons such as former Secretary of State, George Shultz.

    Hmmmmm. Further examination is essential.

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    We need a 2War on Torture.

    The gungho result of our 3War on Terror.

    Futile consequence of always having 'wars' on the doing -- 4War on Drugs, 5War on Poverty -- instead of the doer -- 2sadist, 3saboteur, 4pharmacist, or 5banker?

    Not to mention first, the unformalized War on Segregation, 1950s slang, after Brown v. Board of Ed, instead of making Segregationists the enemy. And the also unofficial War on Medical Abortion, instead of on Religious Fanatics, after Roe v. Wade, '74. (The 'war' was undeclared but its fighters called themselves Christian Soldiers -- transcending 'oxymoron' to a world-class uberoxymoron.)

    We don't have to start it, the next-step 2War on Torture is already being battled.

    Putting Thom's point at the spear tip, we can start the 1War on Distrust.

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    I just received a phone call. It was a recording! It DID NOT say who paid for this crap call! The message? Many people are expressing their views through the Tea Bagging campaign and will be out protesting today! Really? The only campaign of protesters that I have heard of being active today are those fighting to get Single Payer on the table and at the table and the Union buses doing the 'made in America' drives this month! Does this mean that Americans are about to be 'tea bagged' by the anti-democratic press misrepresenting the reasons? Makes me wonder how the protesters will be reported!
    Who has heard of tea baggers out today?

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    I flew a fighter for the AF for 12 years. Until then Defense Secty Dick Cheney cut 500,000 military members in fiscal years 91-93. They didnt want to pay our pensions because they needed the money for thier phony Star Wars program. I flew with a man who spent time in the Hanoi Hilton. For military members who actually put thier lives in harms expect and train to do your duty in an honorable expect your adversary to do the same. Thanks to the Cheney Doctrine of Torture, our soldiers can now fully expect to be subjected to these same methods of interrogation/torture.

  • May 13th 2009 Wednesday   10 years 14 weeks ago

    “Tax cheating” isn’t merely the province of corporations; every day I see or hear an ad from some tax attorney who tells listeners if they owe back taxes, call us and we’ll insure that the IRS treats you with “respect.” They promise to reduce your tax liability to pennies on the dollar. Frankly, as someone who insures his taxes are paid by having no exemptions—and winds-up saving money in the end—I have no respect for such people who dodge their responsibilities to society.
    On yesterday’s topics, I wonder if people like Rep. Bachus are at all concerned how they will look in the history books. The funny thing about history is that the “right” side is generally on the left. When the right tries to rewrite history, as it has tried to do with Reconstruction, they always reveal more about themselves than the history they are re-interpreting. They forget, for example, that killing Yankees and lynching freed slaves was not exactly civilized or lawful behavior, and what followed—peonage and Jim Crow—was hardly worthy of merit in a civilized society. It is hard to figure people who are so far removed from reality that they believe their own lies.
    On the gay marriage issue, I think that the only people who have a problem with gays at all are those who are uncomfortable with the state of their own sex lives. Otherwise, gays, especially those who are white, do not suffer (so long as they are not “in your face” with it, like those “take back the night” marchers with their hetero-hate and misandrist slogans) the same kind of prejudices as, say, someone who cannot hide what society has defined them as. Back in ancient Roman times, the Romans regarded Germanic peoples in terms of physical characteristics and habits that are little differentiated from how so many people today disparage Latino immigrants (and, frankly, even those who are not). It is interesting that even though Germanic immigrants wanted to “assimilate” into the Roman world, incomprehensible prejudices barred that from occurring—even when the empire was on the verge of disintegration (a thousand years later, with the Byzantine Empire in its last throes, the people of Constantinople refused military help from the West due to religious bigotry). It also should be noted that Roman society was economically as stratified as this country is increasingly becoming.

Come Cruise with Thom Hartmann in July 2020

Join me for an exciting Bermuda getaway aboard Oceania Cruises, the world’s leading culinary and destination-focused cruise line. Set sail on the reimagined Insignia for 7 nights beginning July 25th 2020. Take advantage of Oceania Cruises’ OLife Choice promotion, where you can choose shore excursions, a beverage package, or onboard credit – Oceania Cruises also includes Wifi! You'll also receive complimentary gratuities, a $50 onboard credit and two exclusive cocktail parties. Did I mention we are planning special onboard events with yours truly? Prices start at $1199.

Reserve your stateroom today by contacting Keene Luxury Travel, and mention the Thom Hartmann Group 800.856.1155

or go to

The Problem Isn't a "Trade War" - The Problem Is Trump

Thom plus logo The United States needs to protect its domestic economy. We need to protect jobs in manufacturing. We need to rebuild manufacturing. But this needs to come from a comprehensive, coherent, multifaceted strategy that may well include tariffs.