November 9

Barack, Please Listen to Your Base

I am sending the following email to

Dear Barack Obama, I will try to make this letter relatively brief. I am a part of a large, progressive base who supported you in the 2008 election. In my case, I am a progressive blogger as well as a supporter. It has been 2 years now since your election, and I am still a supporter, but events over these past two years have been both alarming and disappointing. We have been disappointed with the people you have surrounded yourself with from the beginning - Rahm Emmanuel, Tim Geithner, Lawrence Summers, and so forth. We have also been disappointed with your top-down response to our financial crisis, although I suppose that was what was to be expected, considering who you were listening to. Helping out the banks wasn't what should have been the real goal. The real goal should have been to help financially strapped citizens. We were appalled when you won the Nobel Peace Prize, but promptly escalated the United States' military presense in Afghanistan. We stood solidly behind you on health care reform and financial regulation. We are happy that legislation was passed, but very disappointed in the intensely compromised legislation that was passed. I thought you had wanted a public option for health insurance, but found out that you had dealt away any chance of having a public option from the beginning.

I have to wonder, why is it that Democrats compromise with Republicans, but Republicans fail to reciprocate? There is a lack of reciprocity in our current system. The social contract is being broken. Democratic politicians, who represent the majority of people in this nation, give in to the demands of right wing terrorist-like Republicans, time and again! What the hell is going on here? I thought this nation was supposed to be a representative democracy, only to find that we have become a corporate plutocracy run by political right-wingers, regardless of who is in the White House. At least, as an interested observer, that is how it seems from here.

Barack, I know that you were elected against long odds, and inherited a horrible situation. I also know that you were a relatively progressive Senator, and believe that you have the heart of a progressive. Furthermore, I believe that you have the public interest at heart, and lastly, I know that you are a brilliant person of outstanding intellect. I have known from the beginning, that moving forward in any sort of progressive way would not be easy. However, I had hoped that at least you would appear to be listening to those among us who believe in "hope and change." That is why I am writing this letter; I am involved in the progressive community here in the United States, so I know that there are a great many of us. Although I can only speak for myself directly, I believe that the majority of Americans feel much the same as I do.

I live in Moreno Valley, California, and in our state, last week's election turned our pretty well from my perspective. However, nationally, it turned out very poorly. Perhaps California is way ahead of the rest of the nation politically, or perhaps our experience with the political temper tantrum that resulted in Arnold Schwarzeneggar's election as Governor, combined with the obvious wealth influence in Meg Whitman's and Carly Fiorina's campaigns. I believe that a combination of these factors influenced California. I also realize that the influx of corporate money due to the Citizen's United decision made things more difficult for Democrats in this election.

However, in my opinion, last week's political temper tantrum which resulted in the election of so many Republicans nationwide, was not a result of voters being convinced that Republican ideas or ideology is superior to that of Democrats. Rather, it was another political temper tantrum much as occured a few years ago in California, with the only point being to punish Democrats for their perceived failures. It is my belief that had your administration paid even modest attention to the wishes of your base, this election would have turned out much better, and our national attitude and economy would be improving at a faster rate. I know that you showed great courage during your campaign, but I have to wonder what happened to it since your election. I think you have tried to play nice with people who don't like you, and don't want to cooperate with you. Perhaps this has to do with the emphasis of progressives on cooperation, while conservatives emphasize individualism. We want to cooperate, while the other side wants to do whatever it can to get into power, and thus, sabotages their opponents rather than engaging in any form of cooperation.

I think this is a good time for you to contemplate this reality, and get tough on those who are frankly, your political enemies, although I am afraid that instead, you will feel the need to compromise even more with the Republicans. There has already been too much compromise! In my view, your compromising is a big part of the problem. I speak from personal knowledge of the way progressives, and to an extent, most Americans think. When asked about what they want, the large majority of Americans in polls support progressive change. However, when they see it not happening, many of them become frustrated to the point of not participating politically, not voting, or voting for the "other party" which they see as the only other viable option in a political system that makes it difficult for any other parties to compete, and which is badly in need of reform such as public financing, instant runoff voting or proportional representation by party voted for, as other nations implement. Many of my friends, or former friends, on Facebook and the Thom Hartmann Community, have turned against your administration, which is tragic, and has caused me to argue with them and lose their friendship. The same is true of many people I know or hear call in to political talk shows.

I know that midterm elections traditionally don't go well for the party in power, so last week's election is no exception in that regard. I expect the election in 2012 to go much better and anticipate you serving as President for another 4 years. However, this may not happen if you don't start representing your base better. Although many such as I will still support you, you need to win back the support of those who have been disillusioned with politics to the point of discontinuing their support of your administration. Also, although I realize that you already understand this as you mentioned it recently, you need to do a much better job of messaging. Most voters are relatively low information voters, and respond mostly to "sound bite" messages and relatively simple, compelling memes, something I know about as a Social Psychologist. I realize that the so-called mainstream media has gone largely corporate and thus tends to be more sympathetic to corporate interests and conservative messages, making the task of messaging more difficult. However, the world is no longer forced to rely on network news the way it used to. The internet, and local radio shows as well, such as Pacifica Radio here in California, have become hugely important messaging sources. In any case, if your administration makes consistent, daily efforts to make its accomplishments known, the information will be spread. Those who refuse to report it, such as Fox news, will likely only be making themselves appear biased, making themselves look bad. Also, you need to work to counteract the influx of corporate money to the political process. Try to make it known what the effects of the Citizens United decision have been, and try to shine a light on where conservatives' campaign money is coming from.

I wish you good luck, and please know that there is a large, progressive community in the United States, I think the majority of Americans in the larger sense. The more you listen to us, the more we will be solidly behind you.

Yours, M. Robert Warden, Jr.


tkmarqs's picture
tkmarqs 9 years 15 weeks ago

Paying Taxes

It all started one night while watching the news…my little boy who is 7 years old, heard me talking (yelling) at the nightly news. He said very calmly, “Mom, maybe you should speak out.” I thought about those words…and he was right. So, now this is me speaking out.

My taxes, our taxes, where do they go? They do not go to a King and his court anymore…our founding fathers made sure of that. As I hear the Republicans scream their mantra “smaller government, less taxes” my blood boils. I see where my taxes go. I drive the roads that lead to my children’s school; I see my taxes in the safe roads that get me there. I see the tax dollars as I drive over the bridges to get to the airport, to take a vacation with my family. I drop my children off for school and I see them wait patiently for the crossing guard to stop traffic as they cross the road to get to class. I am sure that my taxes pay for that crossing guard. I see the teachers who inspire my children everyday, I KNOW my tax dollars go to pay them and in my opinion they should be paid more. I see my children RUN to school because they are excited to go and learn. I see the building that will keep my children warm and safe throughout their day at school, I know my tax dollars went to build it. Their teacher emails me updates, through the telephone wires that bring the internet to the comfort of my home. Who paid for that? I am sure I did through taxes and fees. I see my friend who lost her job and who was pregnant and her husband who barely makes enough to pay the bills. She had her baby, medicare is helping pay for the doctors to keep her and the beautiful little girl she had healthy. I also see my tax dollars on the news when they show the brave men and women who are in the military fighting for our freedom all over the world, who are on night duty protecting and watching over our country.

The Republicans who cry and stomp their feet to extend the Bush Tax Cuts are selfish and spoiled. Now it is their turn to sacrifice to make our country the best in the world. The other 98% of Americans have been doing it for the last 9 years, since the Bush Tax Cuts went into effect. The top 2%, the RICHEST in our country should start contributing to our great country…they say repeatedly they love our country. Well Republicans, put your money where your mouth is.


A Mom in Thornton, CO who works 2 jobs to provide for her family

Natural Lefty's picture
Natural Lefty 9 years 15 weeks ago

tkmarqs, a new voice is heard, and it is yours. You know, the first thing the Repubicans want to do since they successfully thwarted the Obama administration enough to make voters angry and vote against their own interests, for the "other party" is to demand that tax cuts for people with incomes over $250,000 per year will be extended. These are the same people who claim to place a high priority on cutting the huge budget deficit. What a bunch of hypocrits! The sooner these Tea Party people realize that, the better.

What these anti-tax people are doing makes my blood boil, too. I agree too that our tax money has many important uses, without which we would not have much of a society. Well stated, "mom in Thronton CO who works 2 jobs to provide for her family." I went to CO in June, 2008, by the way. Where is Thornton?

Add comment

Login or register to post comments

Come Cruise with Thom Hartmann in July 2020

Join me for an exciting Bermuda getaway aboard Oceania Cruises, the world’s leading culinary and destination-focused cruise line. Set sail on the reimagined Insignia for 7 nights beginning July 25th 2020. Take advantage of Oceania Cruises’ OLife Choice promotion, where you can choose shore excursions, a beverage package, or onboard credit – Oceania Cruises also includes Wifi! You'll also receive complimentary gratuities, a $50 onboard credit and two exclusive cocktail parties. Did I mention we are planning special onboard events with yours truly? Prices start at $1199.

Reserve your stateroom today by contacting Keene Luxury Travel, and mention the Thom Hartmann Group 800.856.1155

or go to

"The Saddest Thing Is This Won't Be Breaking News"

Thom plus logo As the world burns, and more and more fossil fuels are being used every day planet-wide, atmospheric carbon dioxide levels passed 416 ppm this week at the Mauna Loa Observatory in Hawaii. In the 300,000 years since the emergence of modern humans, carbon dioxide levels have never been this high.