Daily Topics - Monday September 20th, 2010

Quote of the Day: “All labor that uplifts humanity has dignity and importance and should be undertaken with painstaking excellence.” -- Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr.

Hour One: Is insuring sick children really so dangerous that it's worth shutting the government down over? Thom challenges Congressman Steve King of Iowa http://steveking.house.gov; Plus, Decent Work for a Decent Wage? Thom talks to Mary Robinson, Former President of Ireland about the global campaign to get the unemployed back to work realizingrights.org

Hour Two: Why are the grande bourgeois mad as hell and threatening to leave America?

Hour Three: Can progressive movement politics really save America? Tim Carpenter, National Director of Progressive Democrats of America. will be here www.pdamerica.org 

Comments

DRichards's picture
DRichards 15 years 28 weeks ago
#1

To deny all morality is to be moral

To deny all morality is to be moral, for the accepted morality is the morality of respectability, and I'm afraid we all crave to be respected - which is to be recognised as good citizens in a rotten society. Respectability is very profitable and ensures you a good job and a steady income. The accepted morality of greed, envy and hate is the way of the establishment. When you totally deny all this, not with your lips but with your heart, then you are really moral. For this morality springs out of love and not out of any motive of profit, of achievement, of place in the hierarchy. There cannot be this love if you belong to a society in which you want to find fame, recognition, a position. Since there is no love in this, its morality is immorality. When you deny all this from the very bottom of your heart, then there is a virtue that is encompassed by love. --- J. Krishnamurti

DRichards's picture
DRichards 15 years 28 weeks ago
#2

As November nears, voters turn backs on both (Corporate owned) partieshttp://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/09/19/AR2010091904664.html

gerald's picture
gerald 15 years 28 weeks ago
#3

Suicide

As a Catholic I have been taught that to commit suicide is a mortal sin and the soul is damned for eternity. This teaching is clear and concise. There should be no problem with the issue of suicide.

An American soldier committed suicide because he refused to torture Iraqi prisoners. As a human being I would not damn this soldier’s soul for all eternity. I am not God and I will have no say in this soldier’s soul and the destiny of his soul. The American soldier in my opinion with his refusal to torture Iraqi prisoners was practicing the Golden Rule and he was obeying the Eleventh Commandment. I look upon this soldier as a true Christian.

The judgment of his soul is in God’s hands.

We have many issues before us that are not clear and concise. There are many issues that have factors, situations, and variables to make our judgment of another person very difficult.

gerald's picture
gerald 15 years 28 weeks ago
#4

The American right are socialists in one area. Yes, the conservatives are really socialists.

http://www.salon.com/news/politics/war_room/2010/09/14/lind_war_socialism

DRichards's picture
DRichards 15 years 28 weeks ago
#6

Re: Suicide

A Minister friend of mine to me the story of when a member of the congregation approached him, and told him that another lady told her that her son was burning in hell because he committed suicide. He asked her if, given the choice, would she condemn her Son to hell for committing suicide? She replied, Oh No! My son was depressed and despondent! My minister friend then told her, then why do you think that God would be less compassionate?

Do we humans have more compassion than God? If so, then what does that have to say about your God? Perhaps the Catholic God is less compassionate. On the other hand, My God is very compassionate!

Lone Star Sean's picture
Lone Star Sean 15 years 28 weeks ago
#7

We should all be Anti-Colonial Kenyans!

Think about it you Newt...If you don't identify with an anti-colonial Kenyan world view, you must support the converse. So apparently Newt is an advocate for the precepts of the British colonial adventure in Kenya. Which, by the by, systematically disempowered Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania, and arguably parts of Somalia and Ethiopia, by undermining their agricultural productivity, deforesting the landscape to relocate resources to enrich England, promoted the subversion of cultural and religious beliefs that pre-date Christanity, and led an entire race of people to question their self worth.

What Newt and others like him fail to understand is summed up by Kenyan author Ngugi wa Thinong'o in his text, Writers in Politics:

"It is time we realized that the European bourgeois experience of history as reflected in their art and literature is not the universal experience of history. Moreover, their history has largely been one of exploitation, oppression and elimination of other peoples" (31).

Newt's "knowledge" of the system is also at play in the process of exploiting the working class, Ngugi writes,

"Racism and racist theories have been effectively used by the ruling Euro-American minority to divide the working majority - Afro-American, Euro-American, Asio-American - by bribing the Euro-American working class with comfortable tidbits of the loot cruelly robbed from the Afto-American workers, and also feeding the Euro-American worker with spurious fascist notions of racial superiority, and the Afro-American worker with equally spurious notions of racial inferiority" (39).

Newt is playing the same old game of divide and conquer.

gerald's picture
gerald 15 years 28 weeks ago
#8

@DRichards, my God is a compassionate God. I brought out the issue on suicide for discussion. On Thom's blog for September 17, 2010 I brought out issues on masturbtion for discussion. I also mentioned obesity. Judgment in the end will depend on God. I pray for a merciful God to judge me. Let me also say that I have seen major changes in Catholic teaching since my K-12 Catholic education. A Mass is now permitted for persons who have committed suicide. Christine O'Donnell is hoping to win political office on the wedge issue of masturbation. My hope was to challenge her nonsense on the issue of masturbation as a clear and concise wedge issue.

Lone Star Sean's picture
Lone Star Sean 15 years 28 weeks ago
#9

We should pray for Newt.

Newt, and other western "intellectuals" like him are victims of the grand narrative...the lie that all positive "evolutionary" inovation in human civilization originated in Europe.

In Writers in Politics, Ngugi continues to explain that the concept that Europe is the center of the universe is really,

"cultural imperialism, a very powerful insturment of oppression since it distorts a people's vision of their place in history and of the reality of the world around them. These distorted literary reflections, often reinforced by religious images of a White God the Father, a White God, the Son and Saviour, and a White God, the Holy Spirit, with a band of white angels singing in heaven while black devils writhe in hell literally paying for their black sins, were meant to lead us, and especially the educated and the christianized along paths of self-doubt and self-hatred to indecisive postures before our enemies" (30-31).

Newt is similarly a victim of the history of western cultural imperialism, and is in a way much like Ngugi as a child, living under a colonial empire set on undermining his entire existance. In his Decolonizing the Mind, Ngugi explains,

"African children who encountered literature in colonial schools and universities were thus experienceing the world as defined and reflected in the European experience of history. Their entire way of looking at the world, even the world of the immediate environment, was Eurocentric. Europe was the centre of the universe. The earth moved around the European intellectual scholarly axis. The images children encountered in literature were reinforced by their study of geography and history, science and technology where Europe was, once again, the centre" (93).

So, you see, Newt is a victim with a child's mind, intellectaully incapable of recognizing the fasle notions to which he bears witness in the public arena.

Lone Star Sean's picture
Lone Star Sean 15 years 28 weeks ago
#10

For the record...

Even in the era of the twit, spelling matters...with names at least:

Ngugi wa Thiong'o

DRichards's picture
DRichards 15 years 28 weeks ago
#11

Re: My God is a compassionate God

Gerald

My apologies if I was not clear; I was not saying this was "your" God, but was using "your" in a general sense. Perhaps I should have said "our". It seemed clear to me that you were referring to the Catholic God, in light of their teaching.

God may not change, but man made religion does. Fortunately, in this case (suicide) for the better (in view of a more compassionate God).

gdspainard33's picture
gdspainard33 15 years 28 weeks ago
#12

Since it seems as though that most independent and republican voters can only handle simple messages. So what I don’t understand is why the campaigns are not pointing out and framing the debate more simply. The republicans are threatening to shut down government. So why are these people running for office not running around screaming that republicans want to starve grandma, and throw you’re unemployed neighbors out of their houses and make them homeless which will intern drive down home prices. Which all are true! Why can’t we get aggressive? Our future as a nation depends on it!

Scooter's picture
Scooter 15 years 28 weeks ago
#13

Just seeing if this still works.

Scooter's picture
Scooter 15 years 28 weeks ago
#14

It does!!! Wow I look GREAT!!!!

Thom's Blog Is On the Move

Hello All

Thom's blog in this space and moving to a new home.

Please follow us across to hartmannreport.com - this will be the only place going forward to read Thom's blog posts and articles.

From The Thom Hartmann Reader:
"Right through the worst of the Bush years and into the present, Thom Hartmann has been one of the very few voices constantly willing to tell the truth. Rank him up there with Jon Stewart, Bill Moyers, and Paul Krugman for having the sheer persistent courage of his convictions."
Bill McKibben, author of Eaarth
From Unequal Protection, 2nd Edition:
"If you wonder why and when giant corporations got the power to reign supreme over us, here’s the story."
Jim Hightower, national radio commentator and author of Swim Against the Current
From The Thom Hartmann Reader:
"Through compelling personal stories, Hartmann presents a dramatic and deeply disturbing picture of humans as a profoundly troubled species. Hope lies in his inspiring vision of our enormous unrealized potential and his description of the path to its realization."
David Korten, author of Agenda for a New Economy, The Great Turning, and When Corporations Rule the World