Recent comments

  • We Need to Stop Worshipping Cops   10 years 26 weeks ago

    So, when was the last time people protested when people are killed by criminals? So, Joe Blow down the street was murdered by another Joe Blow who broke into his home and raped his family then killed the occupants. How many people are going to block traffic over that? What about the many thousands of people who get murdered by guns, knives, clubs, poisoned, etc? If it were not for the police, there would be absolute chaos with many more victims. We would all be huddled in fear. The biggest and most brutish would rule us all. There would be no enforceable laws.

    I don't worship the police but I realize that without a police force that will strike fear in the minds of criminals, they are very close to being totally irrelevant as a protector of the people. Some criminals just don't respect anyone of authority if they know that all they are going to do is to ask them nicely to obey the law. And when many of those criminals, or would-be criminals, get all psyched up with rap music that has lyrics about killing cops and raping women then how do you think they will turn out?

    Most law-abiding people don't have to worry about police brutality or being killed by them. But the criminals just love it when they can get the police to be on the defensive. It serves the criminals very well. Just a moment of hesitation might mean that the criminal can kill that officer before the officer can kill him/her. And that criminal will stay on the streets to possibly rape, rob, or kill other victims. If you don't mind having so many criminals lurking out there then don't even bother about calling the police. You don't like the police...remember?

    It's easy for someone to say that a cop should be like Mr. Rogers..."oh, won't you be my neighbor?". Or, like a frustrated and conflicted parent trying to correct an obstreperous child with useless and unheeded pleas of submission and guilt. Perhaps they will even try the old Santa Claus or God is watching you trick...great ways of introducing paranoia in a person. Hit them with the old superstitions where the antagonists are never seen or heard but imagined. But, the fear of the paddle is way more effective and is a more realistic lesson that will be useful later on in life.

    If you are a law abiding person, you won't challenge the police in any way, not sassing them, acting smart, acting like you are guilty and have something to hide, etc. The police pick up on that right off and it is usually a sure sign that the person is a criminal. It is their duty to catch criminals. So they have to look for the signs that criminals typically show. If you have a problem with the police, signing a traffic ticket for example, then don't be stupid and try to argue with them or refuse to sign the ticket. If you escalate the tension with the police, it will never work out in your favor. Take it up in court later.

  • Politics Panel - How Many Sorority Girls Have Been Rectally Fed?   10 years 26 weeks ago

    Why no mention of the School of the Americas (cum: The Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation)?

    Roland

  • We Need to Stop Worshipping Cops   10 years 26 weeks ago

    ChicagoMatt ~ Your argument shocks me. What is so complicated about AIW's suggestion. We here in the Bay Area have the same problem and want the same solution. This has nothing to do with segregation at all. You simply draw a line around a police precinct. The only officers that are eligible to work within that line must also live within that line. This has nothing at all to do with race. This has to do with basic geography. As far as your suggestion about other public workers like firemen, teachers, and garbage men goes, I think the answer is a no brainer--yes. Nothing to do with racism, all to do with common sense. People need to live closer to their places of work. We need to cut down on our dependance on oil; and, the only way to do that is by putting peoples residences closer to their locations of work. It is better for the worker, for the community; and, ultimately, for the planet.

  • We Need to Stop Worshipping Cops   10 years 26 weeks ago

    Oh bullshit, Matt. Pre-segregation, my ass. How about people's right to representation? Communities are best served by those living in those communities. Like I pointed out already, this generates rapport and a sense of trust between the officer and those under his (or her) watch. A community needs the presence of law enforcement officers with a personal stake in that community. It’s a win-win for both the police and the policed. By dragging firemen, teachers, garbagemen and so on into this, Matt, you are only watering down the focus of the discussion. Firemen, teachers and garbagemen don’t go around armed with pistols in holsters, nor do they have the power to arrest and detain people on the streets. Gimmie a break.

  • How the New Economic Boom Left Behind the Poor & Middle Class   10 years 26 weeks ago

    What economic boom? Since all monies are redirected to the wealthy, stocks, the things they buy, have increased in price. This is just localized inflation, nothing like any kind of boom. As America fails it will suck the parasites down with it.

    Roland

  • Full Show 12/23/2014: The Right’s Attack on de Blasio   10 years 26 weeks ago

    Stripey,

    You are correct, sir.

    Roland

    P.S.: I think it was really the National Security priests, the same who convinced LBJ to continue the Viet Nam war if he did not want to share JFK's fate.

  • We Need to Stop Worshipping Cops   10 years 26 weeks ago
    The obvious solution to item #4 is to have police officers serving the communities they live in, where they have a rapport with the residents of those communities and a personal stake in the outcomes of their own police work. I’ve heard and read this point made up, down and sideways, via more sources than I could possibly recall. So why haven’t policies like this been established? A question worthy of further scrutiny.

    Because that's re-segregation, and no one wants to admit that the de-segregation policies of the 50s and 60s failed.

    First, you have to have entire cities with populations of a single race, since police are hired at the city level. While there are several small towns that are all one race, there are few cities like that.

    Then, you have to hire police officers based on their race. The definition of racism.

    And why stop there? Why not the other public workers, like firemen, teachers, garbagemen, etc. All the same race - the same race as the population.

    Might as well go ahead and form different countries and be done with it.

  • Is the Koch Brothers' Curriculum Coming to Your Child's School?   10 years 26 weeks ago
    Matt, religion belongs in church. Science belongs in school. That's not me pushing a personal agenda on anybody; that's the separating of church and state

    Like many others, I argue that science/secularism is a religion in itself. At least it is a belief system, just as religions are. It's a way of explaining the world around you.

    Alice has a belief system - that science/secularism is not a religion. If Alice wants the school her children attend to teach that, that's Alice's right. But saying that EVERY school MUST teach that, now you're imposing your beliefs on others.

    There are many religions practiced in this multicultural, multiethnic country of ours.
    Exactly. That's why we need local community curriculum planning, not State or Federal planning. The only thing a Department of Education should do is license teachers.

  • The Death of the Middle Class was by Design...   10 years 26 weeks ago

    Chicago Matt, the destruction of the middle class coincides with the prevalence of the wearing of blue jeans but I don't think one caused the other. The traditional family is no stronger in Western European countries that continue to have a strong middle class.
    There's nothing wrong with education but college is now just a source of debt as banksters have learned to game the system. Unlike before, the middle class is out of reach for anyone without higher education. Labor is now very weak.
    Indebting Americans is a good example of the willful and deliberate destruction of the middle class.

  • How Global Warming Harms Your Health...   10 years 26 weeks ago

    The legal corporate mandate to maximize profit can be rephrased as 'extract as much as possible from the physical/social environment.' The long term result of this behavior by all corporations is an inevitable collapse of the environment and, of course, the capitalist economic system. Stated briefly, the corporate system, when uncontrolled, will self-destruct taking all else with it.

  • How Global Warming Harms Your Health...   10 years 26 weeks ago

    Nice study. It is certainly true that most of us only have the bookish knowledge.. and we are unaware of the practical hazards to our health with this.

  • We Need to Stop Worshipping Cops   10 years 26 weeks ago

    Reply to posts #13 & #19: Eatraum, you’ve repeatedly pointed out the obvious: that policing is a difficult job, one that most of us have not elected to do. Nobody’s going to argue those points, least of all me. BUT what is also true is the fact that no one is forced at gunpoint to enter that profession either. And what these various murder-by-cop incidents have proven, time & again, is that (1) We still have a race problem in America, and a class war, simultaneously influencing how police work is practiced in our communities; (2) Whatever "training" these officers-in-training received was inadequate; (3) Policing, as a profession, is attracting people with the wrong attitude and temperament for the job; and (4) Too many racist bullies with loose trigger fingers are wearing the badge. These guys are clearly not “serving” or “protecting” those they are supposed to be serving and protecting. Intimidation and control is more like it. And there is no reason why any unarmed person should EVER have to be shot. There are plenty of non-lethal means cops could be using to apprehend their subjects, so why aren’t they using them?

    The obvious solution to item #4 is to have police officers serving the communities they live in, where they have a rapport with the residents of those communities and a personal stake in the outcomes of their own police work. I’ve heard and read this point made up, down and sideways, via more sources than I could possibly recall. So why haven’t policies like this been established? A question worthy of further scrutiny.

    Beyond that, there needs to be a much more rigorous screening process for policing candidates, to weed out predators of all stripes: the racists, the misogynists, the perverts, along with standard, run-of-the-mill bullies and control freaks. These types of personalities are attracted to policing for obvious reasons. They are the ones giving policing a bad name. The militarization of police departments doesn’t help either. Decked out and armed like military invaders, these guys act as though they were occupiers in a foreign country, and tend to treat people accordingly, more as enemy combatants than as citizens... ESPECIALLY in communities of color. This is enormously destructive to the society at large. It plays a major role in what is poisoning race relations in this country. Keeps those old xenophobic attitudes reinforced on both sides of the proverbial tracks. I believe this benefits only a small elite class of kleptofascists whose interests are best served by keeping the "masses" divided, at each other's throats and therefore, too distracted to recognize the magnitude of what is being taken from us and destroyed.

    The behavior of the police often is what triggers any violence that occurs. I’ve seen it over and over again at peaceful protests, where no crimes are being committed prior to police attacks. It is disgusting. But it is worth remembering that stirring up trouble at peaceful demonstrations serves the same interests as stop-and-frisk type policies. I’ve seen it with my own eyes, in person as well as on video, where people get attacked by police officers, with little to no provocation. Between that and racial profiling, and the stop-and-frisk types of policies and practices targeting people of color (decided by city legislatures, by the way, not by the public; often not with the public's best interests in mind), we see ample opportunity for bad cops to abuse the power entrusted to them. And what about the horrible crimes committed by those men wearing the badge, who should never have entered that profession in the first place?! And why should the blemishes bad cops leave on policing’s public image surprise anyone paying attention to all this?

    What’s going on in our country today is a class war in which racism helps fuel the flames. Unfortunately these militarized police forces have played a major role in that ongoing drama, where real lives are destroyed on a daily basis and often arbitrarily; where ramming down people’s doors in the wee hours of the morning, terrorizing and shooting them in their own homes constitutes business as usual. The seizure & forfiture of people’s personal property by the police, often without evidence, let alone charge or trial, is indefensible. This sort of "police work" would be unacceptable in any genuinely decent, civilized society. It constitutes theft with impunity on the part of “law enforcement”, further eroding the credability of the police in the eyes of the policed. It clearly is an abuse of power. This kind of shit has got to stop if there is ever to be a relationship of trust and mututal respect, between police and the communities they “serve”.

    Abuse inflicted on the public by bad cops, however many or few there are, is a reality we ignore only at our peril if a free & open society is what we really want. I’m talking about murders, rapes and torture committed by police officers, on prisoners of both sexes, hardly unheard of in this grrreat country. I’m talking about unarmed black men arbitrarily executed in the streets, usually in broad daylight, with no indictments let alone prosecutions ever forthcoming on these trigger-happy cops. Is our outrage over that not justified?

    When your answer to that, eatraum, is to defensively remind us that good cops exist, you’re not telling us anything most of us don’t already know. And it’s not helpful, because the problem persists despite the fact that good cops exist. Yes there are good cops performing their duties well, even with heroism, in behalf of others caught in some of the most perilous circumstances imaginable. But the fact remains, there’s enough bad policing going on to make its presence known, thus showing by example that as a society, we have a problem. The so-called “war on drugs” (translation: war on drug users, especially in poor communities of color) has been a major factor in that equasion.

    The solutions to such problems don’t seem all that complicated. But as usual, politics gets in the way. I believe these kinds of issues involving the police are symptomatic of something much larger, but I’ll save that for another conversation. - AIW

  • Politics Panel - Fox News is tearing apart NYC...   10 years 26 weeks ago

    The segment couldn't even stay on topic because our news sources are so corrupt, we have to argue about the facts before we can even discuss the situation. We really need to get ownership of news programs out of the hands of the corporations. Our only news comes from each other via internet ... and the corporations want that, too.

  • How Global Warming Harms Your Health...   10 years 26 weeks ago

    The most important documentary of the year is "Cowspiracy." It begins and ends every conversation about our precious environment. There is no point in enumerating the symptoms of an unhealthy environment when the cause is so obvious.

  • Has 2014 been a historic year for social movements & protests?   10 years 26 weeks ago

    Things will change when people feel threatened but we humans get lazy about about life when things are OK. Thomas Jefferson knew we would always have to keep a revolutionary spirit if we wanted a true democracy. Of course, he needed to free his slaves and he never did that. We become philosophers when we need to become activists, as Thoreau and M. Gandhi knew well.

  • Will the Case Against Darren Wilson Be Reopened?   10 years 27 weeks ago

    Give it a rest. Most of the "false" evidence came from people lying about seing Wilson shoot Brown in the back, etc. Quit beating a dead horse and race baiting. 2 cops were murdered in NYC. Isn't that enough?

  • How Global Warming Harms Your Health...   10 years 27 weeks ago

    Please read FILES on ===> Peace n Planting <====open group on Facebook

    Feed ALL children worldwide for ONE MILLION $$$ per each BILLION spent on WAR.

    FIGHTING costs WAY MORE than FEEDING !!

    Feed ALL children Educate ALL people

    to feed themselves and others

    Our RIGHT is to establish ideal human habitat; our DUTY for 7 generations. ALL kept as PUBLIC BENEFIT controlled only by real HUMANS, on GAIA our living planet.

    FOOD CEREMONIES generate PEACEFUL COMMUNICATION

    Gather in fields: the congregation.

    Plant seeds: the ceremony.

    PRAY during the growing/watering.

    Share WORLDWIDE: the communion.

    Peace n Planting ===>our true way of life see open group on F'bk

    99% feel the same ...... Feed ALL children Educate ALL people

    Please BEE REAL -- get a hive going with somebody anywhere!

    BEE ProACTIVE aka benefit the 7 generations in all you do!

    PS MAKING IT HAPPEN LOCALLY in your neighborhood.

    Thought this local action peace plan might be at the heart of our prayers.... we could rent church kitchens and make wonderful BREAKFAST in YOUR POCKET cookies and donated organic milk for school children. Friday night we use the kitchen again to make WHOLE GRAIN PIZZA with ten vegetables and mushrooms. Salad bar too, all organic fresh!

    NO MOVIE NIGHTS -- instead there are ten tables with crafts and skills mentors sitting there to help the YOUTH. A great fisherman, a basket maker, leather worker, food preservation teacher and other useful survival skills teachers /life guides.

    Create "living rooms" see GREENHOUSE 2020 below....cost $500 with local rough cut lumber & 10mil reinforced cover!

  • We Need to Stop Worshipping Cops   10 years 27 weeks ago

    Not everybody's on the same page. The cop murderers must've thought they were "getting even".
    Violent methods almost always harm a nascent movement. They turn people against it and make them less likely to join it and serve as a justification for violent repression by the authorities - so much so that reactionary authorities often anonymously commit acts of violence and blame them on the movement or send provocateur infiltrators to goad the movement's members to adopt violence.
    The protesters perhaps should denounce the cop killings more publicly and more vocally.

  • We Need to Stop Worshipping Cops   10 years 27 weeks ago

    Fuzzyboo,

    I agree many of your points as well. We are most definately in a complex pickle as a society. But, to our discussion I go.

    There are many details and examples of injustice , brutality and over reaction on both sides. However, generalized reactionary and vitriolic animadversion will serve no one but the profferers of discord. Leaders must be calm and strategic. They must stand above the fray and look at the battle, searching for a way to end the conflict with mutually beneficial potential. To do this a leader has to be able to see the positives in his adversary and work with those just as he or she fights against the negatives.

    I still disagree with Mr. Hartmann's contention that officers should not be seen as heroes in our society.

    I think you would agree that, while many officers are overreaching in their use of authority, most are disciplined and hard working risk takers who see their duty as that of holding society to the laws that have been passed by our legislators. I certainly agree with you that corporations have gained control of our government and that police officers are tasked with enforcement of those laws generated on their behalf. History has shown that this slow descent into fascism will continue until the pain becomes so great that the majority of the populace is moved to action. VOTING is our best action and we have to take accountability for the lack thereof. Contiuing to focus on the actions of the police is a tactical mistake. By vewing the police as our adversaries we cannot concentrate on the true adversary, which is, of course, the corporations and their owners; the 1%.

    I have been on the street for many years and I know the risks that police officers take. Criticism is certainly due but they are heroic to me and I, personally, think it is the weak of character who live the life we have in America but become censorius of all officers due to highly publicized actions of a small percentage of them.

    My main, tactical point in our discussion is that we need to recognize the benefits that police bring to our lives and appreciate the risks they take. My strategic point is that it serves us to see the police as a representation of us as a society and that we need, as you expertly described, to focus on the true source of our growing dilemma; fascism. Enmity divides. Patience and strategic empathy unite.

    Thank you for challenging my in my comments. I appreciate your input and thought.

    Ed

  • Full Show 12/23/2014: The Right’s Attack on de Blasio   10 years 27 weeks ago

    Thom, you're unfortunately incorrect in saying President Carter didn't start any wars. In a 1998 interview, his national security adviser Zbigniew Brzezinski confirmed that Carter approved his plan to aid the tribal/feudal/fundamentalist mujehedin in Afghanistan five months *before* the Soviet invasion of that country: http://nadeemmalik.wordpress.com/2011/05/10/osama-bin-laden-us-national-...

  • We Need to Stop Worshipping Cops   10 years 27 weeks ago

    The march to authoritarianism is well under way. Most Americans approve of torture and have worshipped cops - or at least foolishly idolized them - for some time already. Since Ronald Reagan most presidents had been Republican father figures or big brother figures in the image of the strong man most Americans seem to wish for - and are very willing to give extraordinary "emergency" power to to "protect" us with.
    Most Americans - and perhaps most people - are not capable of democracy. They abhor authoritarianism or tyranny - if it contradicts their own values. They laud and support authoritarianism or tyranny if it upholds their personal values. They abhor tyranny if it isn't THEIR tyranny but if it is they're all in favor of it.
    That includes lefties like Thom - or at least he's not as immune to that inclination as he seems to think.

  • A Warren Run Would Change Everything   10 years 27 weeks ago

    Richard, I’ve already made my feelings very clear regarding Ms. Warren and Mr. Sanders’ deference to Israel. I don’t know what “reasoning” you’re referring to. And I didn’t mean to suggest we all sit around waiting for politicians to do something. I believe we need another mass movement like the one in opposition to the Vietnam War. (I don’t know what it is about my “assessment” of that war you disagree with, by the way.) I just don’t know what it’s going to take to motivate enough people to get involved in such a movement. I don’t see much evidence of that where I live. Just business as usual. - AIW

  • How Global Warming Harms Your Health...   10 years 27 weeks ago

    I just want to voice this Christmas Wish for people OF Good Will.

    Are you depressed by what the predatory greedballs that are ruining the biosphere have done and continue planning to do? Is your, logical and rational, evidence based fear that these powerful Homo SAPS are hell bent on their suicidal predation causing you to feel dejected and sad?

    You aren't alone. And because there are a LOT more of us than there are of THEM, never lose faith that we-the-people of Good Will shall prevail.

    Graphic to cheer you up:

    http://www.createaforum.com/gallery/renewablerevolution/3-231214183727.jpeg

    "Peace on Earth to men OF Good Will" graphic:

    http://www.createaforum.com/gallery/renewablerevolution/3-231214194953.jpeg

    Merry Christmas!

    Spread the cheer to people OF Good Will, pass the graphics on.

    PEOPLE OF GOOD WILL ARE WINNING! Fossil Fuels are now OFFICALLY more expensive than RENEWABLE ENERGY!

    Renewable Energy PROVEN to be CHEAPER than Fossil Fuels and other facts on Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Energy

    http://renewablerevolution.createaforum.com/renewables/the-big-picture-of-renewable-energy-growth/msg2440/#msg2440

  • How Global Warming Harms Your Health...   10 years 27 weeks ago

    Astute and important observations. For many years, have lived close to Richmond, CA -- a home of a huge Chevron Oil refinery for much of the past 100 years. The incidence of respiratory disease in Richmond is dramatically higher than in many other portions of the San Francisco Bay Area.

  • How Global Warming Harms Your Health...   10 years 27 weeks ago

    THANK YOU THOM and everyone who is facing the very real threats of Climate Disruption and taking action. www.OurGreenChallenge.org for helpful tips.

ADHD: Hunter in a Farmer's World

Thom Hartmann has written a dozen books covering ADD / ADHD - Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder.

Join Thom for his new twice-weekly email newsletters on ADHD, whether it affects you or a member of your family.

Thom's Blog Is On the Move

Hello All

Thom's blog in this space and moving to a new home.

Please follow us across to hartmannreport.com - this will be the only place going forward to read Thom's blog posts and articles.