Transcript: Thom Hartmann: The Big Picture: The "Takers" vs. the "Makers". 25 May '11

Any good war effort needs an effective P.R. strategy. A campaign to specify just who the enemy is - and why they should be defeated - how else do you rally support? So when it comes to the Republican war on the working class - who do you think they turned to for help with messaging?

Fox News - well, Fox Business Channel actually. All this week - Fox is running segments named "Entitlement Nation: Makers versus Takers"….take a look:

LOU DOBBS: All week this week, Fox Business presenting a special series called "Entitlement Nation, Makers Versus Takers," on the nation's growing dependence on government handouts. Peter Barnes and Ashley Webster here with two reports tonight. Peter, let's begin with you.

ANDREW NAPOLITANO: And the feds give away more money than they collect in taxes. The money is doled out primarily in the form of entitlements like Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid. Not only are these problems unconst -- or, these programs unconstitutional, as the federal government is not authorized to take money from one group and give it to another, but they make Americans dependent upon big government

DAVID ASMAN: Kicking off tonight, for several weeks now, Scoreboard has been featuring a segment called 'Makers and Takers,' which we think embodies the great divide in this country between the folks who actually make things, and those who actually take what others make.]

Right…they say there’s a war going on in America - a war that pits the rich - or the makers - against the poor - the takers.

And Republicans accuse Democrats of playing class warfare??

First off - the premise of this war is completely absurd - as if rich people are having ANYTHING taken away from them today in America. Their tax rates are at historic lows - with the richest Americans - billionaire Walton heirs or Paris Hilton's or hedge fund managers sitting on their butts by the pool collecting their dividend checks in the mail and paying only 15% in taxes - far less that what you and I pay.

Can you name one thing that any of these folks are actually MAKING - other than a boatload of money? Today - the richer are richer than they’ve ever been since right before the Great Depression.

The wealth inequality is greater than it’s ever been since right before the Great Depression.

The "makers" - as Fox calls them - have never had it so good in America…so why does Fox make it look like they’re under assault by so-called “takers”? It’s simple - Republicans need to re-brand Paul Ryan's radical budget plan that privatizes Medicare and destroys our social safety net in America.

It’s all about politics - and singling out an enemy.

Ronald Reagan was the first to single out poor people as the enemy with his “welfare queen” campaigns - and today - Republicans have picked up the same message with their "takers" meme. As though the millions of people who lost their jobs and homes thanks to banksters on Wall Street crashing our economy REALLY WANT to be on welfare.

As though they ENJOY the stigma attached to welfare - they enjoy scraping pennies together to feed their family - they enjoy not being able to buy their kids Christmas presents.

What kind of warped view of America do these right-wingers have when they argue that tens of millions of Americans are nothing but moochers?

I don't know about you - but I don't see that when I look at my country. These people don’t enjoy poverty and welfare.

People who’ve fallen on hard times want to get back on their feet again - they just need some help. And as Franklin Roosevelt said - the best welfare program is a job.

But guess what? The “makers” aren’t making any jobs…in America at least they’re making millions of jobs overseas - but barely any here in America.

And the policies that DO create jobs - like closing tax breaks that ship jobs overseas - Republicans filibustered and Fox News bashed.

The problem in America is not that the takers have taken too much from the makers. It's that the "makers" have taken too much from everyone else - screwing all of us - without really making anything.

But this "makers" versus "takers" war isn't anything new. Ayn Rand referred to the conflict as "producers" versus "looters" - rich industrialists versus workers and the poor.

Despite her disturbing ideas - Ayn Rand is a hit among Republicans - in particular - Paul Ryan...take a look:

REP. PAUL RYAN (R-WI): Ayn Rand more than anyone else did a fantastic job of explaining the morality of capitalism, the morality of individualism... So if Ayn Rand were here today I think she would do a great job in showing us just how wrong what government is doing is... It’s that kind of thinking, that kind of writing that is sorely needed right now.

Paul Ryan also makes his staff read Rand's books, so please don't burst his bubble by pointing out that Ayn Rand herself went on Medicare when she became eligible.

And now Fox is taking this same radical philosophy and devoting an entire week to promoting it.

So let's tell it how it is. The real "makers" in our society are the people creating demand by buying things.

Remember what George W. Bush said after 9/11?

"Go shopping!"

Even Bush understood that the real "makers" in our society are the consumers and the wage-workers, not the guys out playing golf on a Wednesday.

Even people on Social Security or unemployment are "makers" because they're spending every penny they get, and their consumer spending is what drives the economy.

This isn't a nation of makers and's a nation of makers with a couple thousand millionaires and billionaires looting what's left.

As the richest man in America, Warren Buffett, pointed out, there IS a class war in America - and his class is winning it.

They are the real takers - and at least Buffett is honest enough to admit it and even work to try to change it.

If Fox is going to focus-group for the Republican Party and the nation's billionaires, the least they could do is take the word "News" out of their name.

That's The Big Picture.

Coronavirus: Many Claim We Can't Afford Medicare-for-all, But, It Appears We Are About To Discover How Costly Our For-Profit Healthcare Is

Thom plus logo The coronavirus is now in the United States, and apparently the infection in California goes beyond just one person, because they can't figure out how that one person got it. Which means lots of people need to get tested, particularly if they have symptoms of a severe cold or flu which could indicate that they have the coronavirus.

Latest Headlines

Who rejected United States-North Korea peace talks?

There were conflicting reports on Sunday regarding a recent proposal for United States-North Korea peace talks which was allegedly made before North Korea"s recent nuclear test

U.K. Pound Falls As Markets Get Brexit Jitters

Bloomberg said on Monday the pound had sustained its biggest fall against the dollar in 11 months

Clinton: I'll defend Israel but push for 'two-state solution

Hillary Clinton believes both Republican candidates Donald Trump and Ted Cruz "missed the mark" with their approach to the Israel-Palestinian Arab conflict
From Screwed:
"I think many of us recognize that for all but the wealthiest, life in America is getting increasingly hard. Screwed explores why, showing how this is no accidental process, but rather the product of conscious political choices, choices we can change with enough courage and commitment. Like all of Thom’s great work, it helps show us the way forward."
Paul Loeb, author of Soul of a Citizen and The Impossible Will Take a Little While
From Cracking the Code:
"Thom Hartmann ought to be bronzed. His new book sets off from the same high plane as the last and offers explicit tools and how-to advice that will allow you to see, hear, and feel propaganda when it's directed at you and use the same techniques to refute it. His book would make a deaf-mute a better communicator. I want him on my reading table every day, and if you try one of his books, so will you."
Peter Coyote, actor and author of Sleeping Where I Fall
From Cracking the Code:
"No one communicates more thoughtfully or effectively on the radio airwaves than Thom Hartmann. He gets inside the arguments and helps people to think them through—to understand how to respond when they’re talking about public issues with coworkers, neighbors, and friends. This book explores some of the key perspectives behind his approach, teaching us not just how to find the facts, but to talk about what they mean in a way that people will hear."
to understand how to respond when they’re talking about public issues with coworkers, neighbors, and friends. This book explores some of the key perspectives behind his approach, teaching us not just how to find the facts, but to talk about what they mean in a way that people will hear."