Is This the Smoking Gun of Trump's Treason?

Thom plus logo Trump's trial may have to shift from insurrection to treason

Probably the largest question that the Trump impeachment trial must answer is both simple and straightforward: "Did the President lead or participate in a conspiracy to overthrow the government of the United States and install himself as a strongman dictator-for-life?"

Proving this first requires connecting Trump to the traitors who actually, physically tried to seize the Capitol and murder Vice President Mike Pence and Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, killing five other people in the process.

It'll also require proof that Trump or people in his immediate circle directed that insurrection with his knowledge; that he himself directed people to march on the capital and suggested or implied they should act violently; and that he or his agents took active steps to prevent the federal government from protecting the Capitol or Pence, Pelosi, and the constitutional process of counting the votes.

New reporting from the New York Times brings shocking detail to this investigation, and a recently released document raises troubling questions.

First, it appears that the invasion of the Capitol to "stop the steal" wasn't spontaneous, but was the result of a conspiracy that promoted it directly to the people who ultimately carried it out.

"The rally had taken on new branding, the March to Save America, and other groups were joining in, among them the Republican Attorneys General Association," the Times reporters noted. "Its [RAGA's] policy wing, the Rule of Law Defense Fund, promoted the event in a robocall that said, 'We will march to the Capitol building and call on Congress to stop the steal,' according to a recording obtained by the progressive investigative group Documented."

Additionally, there are multiple reports of a shadowy meeting the evening before, January 5, at the Trump Hotel in Trump's private suite that may be a key to a possible conspiracy to overthrow the American government the following day.

An associate of Alabama Senator Tommy Tuberville, "the then-director of the Republican Attorneys General Association," noted on Facebook that Tuberville was among the participants, although the Senator has since denied it. His denials notwithstanding, multiple photos of him in the Trump Hotel and purported to have been taken on that night have surfaced.

The rally on the ellipse was put together by a group called Women for America First, but they had no plans to march to the Capital building and certainly had no plans to engage in a violent overthrow of the American government.

But when Trump and his colleagues showed up at the rally, he and others specifically called for a march to the Capitol building.

Trump even announced that he would march with the crowd, although after he left his speaking position behind his bulletproof glass, he instead took his bulletproof limousine back into the White House.

Speaking of the original, peaceful rally organizers, the Times noted:

"Mr. Stockton said he was surprised to learn on the day of the rally that it would now include a march from the Ellipse to the Capitol."

The Times added, "Before the White House became involved, he said, the plan had been to stay at the Ellipse until the counting of state electoral slates was completed."

Trump, of course, specifically directed the crowd to march on the Capitol when he spoke at the rally.

Which may bring us to Acting Defense Secretary Christopher Miller and the memo he wrote 2 days before the assault on the Capitol.

The memo has been leaked in the last few years days and is widely circulating on the Internet. If authentic, it appears to explicitly block the DC National Guard from playing any sort of meaningful role in supporting the Capitol Police to defend the Capitol building, the Vice President or any Members of Congress.

Jan 4 letter from the Acting Secretary of Defense

If authenticated, it appears to direct the Secretary of the Army that the DC National Guard may not assist the Capitol Police in any meaningful way without a specific, direct authorization from Miller himself.

If I'm reading this memo right, the DC National Guard is specifically forbidden from offering any sort of intelligence or logistical support including drones or helicopters, using tear gas or other riot control agents, or helping arrest insurrectionists who may storm the Capitol.

As Mark Ames writes for National Memo: "The full memo shows that the D.C. Guard did receive a request from D.C. government for guard presence during the Jan. 6 event. Miller responds promptly to go ahead, so long as the soldiers are given no weapons, no body armor, and no helmets. They can bring agents like pepper spray or flashbangs. They can't share any gear with Capitol Police or Metro D.C. Police. They can't ... really do much of anything."

He adds that this is probably why the National Guard was directing traffic rather than defending the Capitol on January 6th.

As a result, according to the Capitol Police's Union Chairman Gus Papathanasiou: "We have one officer who lost his life as a direct result of the insurrection. Another officer has tragically taken his own life. Between USCP and our colleagues at the Metropolitan Police Department, we have almost 140 officers injured. I have officers who were not issued helmets prior to the attack who have sustained brain injuries. One officer has two cracked ribs and two smashed spinal disks. One officer is going to lose his eye, and another was stabbed with a metal fence stake."

Other reporting suggests Miller was simply defining what the Capitol Police could ask the DC National Guard for, but that the Capitol Police inexplicably ignored FBI and other warnings of impending violence and a request for help didn't come until well after the siege was underway.

Vanity Fair's reporting has Acting Secretary of Defense Miller claiming that Trump threw him "under the bus," rather than that he helped Trump make sure the Capitol was left defenseless.

Presumably these details will come out at Trump's impeachment trial in the Senate next week.

If it turns out that Trump and his cronies conspired to co-opt the peacefully planned Women For America First rally and turn it into an assault on the Capitol, that they encouraged or explicitly called for the march to and seizure of the Capitol, and that they took active measures to leave the Capitol defenseless, America is looking at something far worse than an impeachment.

If such a conspiracy had been successful and Mike Pence and Nancy Pelosi (among others) today lay dead, the electoral count was flipped, and Trump had been re-installed as President For Life (as he'd "jokingly" called for numerous times in the past) , it would have been the end of our republic.

Americans have a right to know if Trump and his associates tried to overthrow the government of the United States, the literal definition of treason. And, if it can be proven that they did, we have the right and obligation to demand justice.


Originally posted on


DrRichard 2 years 16 weeks ago

Beginning to sound more and more like the Beer Hall Putsch.

Legend 2 years 16 weeks ago

Republicons are desperately playing this down because they know that it goes deep into the roots of the party.

norgotoad's picture
norgotoad 2 years 16 weeks ago

There were 2 major attacks against the USA in the 21st century involving hostile insurgent/ terrorist forces against 2 major cities: 9/11 attack against New York WTC and DC against the Pentagon, and the 1/6 attack against the Capitol. In both attacks neither the multi-trillion dollar defense dept., nor the law enforcement agencies were even more than minimally effective in protecting these very high profile targets if they even bothered to show up. In fact, on 1/6 members of these agencies were either collaborators with the attackers or looked like the Three Stooges go to a riot. Why are we over funding these demonstrably useless agencies? Law enforcement is so compromised by the right wing that a bunch of fence posts acting as police would be just as effective. The courts and justice dept. will probably barely investigate the right wing insurgents let alone bring most into custody. If they do, these criminals will probably be cite-released and OR'd. No consequences. No cost. Repeated treasonous acts are almost guaranteed. In fact, why not?

Legend 2 years 16 weeks ago

Both were under Republican administrations. Both have a lot of inside information that was ignored, deliberately? More and more will come out.

deepspace's picture
deepspace 2 years 16 weeks ago

The most valuable aspect of impeachment is to get it on record as a warning to the future that egregious behavior cannot and will not be tolerated. Trump is a twice-impeached president forever. Will Republicans make him a twice-acquitted, guilty-as-hell traitor and themselves aiders and abettors forever? "Fool me twice, shame on me."

Riverplunge's picture
Riverplunge 2 years 16 weeks ago

I long for the days, where we could just vote an offender out.

Today, there are too many of offenders, and not enough voting booths.

If I were to to knock down a country with hatred,

I would be jailed for treason.

But if I were GOP - Meh; they'll give it a pass and let me go.

Could they be so bitter that they would risk going to jail.

Just to see their side win?

Could it be, it's just the satifaction?

So they do it again!

alis volat's picture
alis volat 2 years 16 weeks ago

This situation and the folks involved are the personification of Trump's legacy, literally. He will be known for little else. Fifty years from now this is the trivia question that will be asked about him in an American bar on the moon or Mars.

I hope everyone will take heart about the bad-actors involved. They will be facing criminal court in the federal system, and it's all on tape: "Federal crimes are prosecuted by Assistant U.S. Attorneys and investigated by federal officers, such as FBI or DEA agents. State crimes are investigated by county sheriffs, state agents, or local police officers, and prosecuted by state district attorneys or city attorneys."

Suffice it to say, this bit of history is being examined and is far from being over. Trump has escaped justice his whole life, maybe the universe saved it all up for 2021.

cuz's picture
cuz 2 years 16 weeks ago

Good morning Sue, I believe you said you are the person that posts Thoms columns. I understand he makes his entire living opposing his imagined foe but, in the last 90 days has Thom written one column that does not contain the word, Trump? Is there more than one or two that offer hope for the future of our country? Asking for a friend.

Groucho Marks said it best,

"Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it everywhere, diagnosing it incorrectly, and applying the wrong remedies"

Steve S56's picture
Steve S56 2 years 16 weeks ago

@cuz: Apparently there are millions like you who want to just sweep this whole thing under the rug. It is vitally important that trump and the GOP be held accountable for not just 1/6, but for aiding and abetting trump's big lie. Trump is a malefactor, but he couldn't have gotten away with his criminality without a lot GOP sycophants and cynics who were okay with trump if he would appoint a bevy of right-wing justices to the federal bench.

stopgap's picture
stopgap 2 years 16 weeks ago

Hey Cuz, It’s Groucho Marx, not “Marks.” Duh!!! Why would you be quoting one of those "pedophile, baby eating, outer space laser forest burning" Jewish people in the first place? No doubt, Maggie Taylor Greene would consider the Jewish, Marx quote, leftwing propaganda.

Better stick with Hitler, Mussolini and Trump for your quotes!

cuz's picture
cuz 2 years 16 weeks ago

Stopgap, thank you for the correction. I was talking to a co-worker as I was typing and Marx came out as Marks. I appreciate your calling it to my attention.

deepspace's picture
deepspace 2 years 16 weeks ago

"These aren't the droids you're looking for." Trump who? Never heard of him. The last 90 days never happened. Republicans need to move along. Let's talk about happier subjects again, like evil socialism and baby-eating Democrats ...oh God, I beg of you, please, oh please, oh please!

Heh, heh... just offering a little friendly business advice and asking to reset the agenda ...ah, for a friend. Wait, what? "A few of your personality type appears on every forum or blog regardless of its subject matter People usually refer to them as wannabee moderators."

Been around the block "on every forum or blog" trolling, eh? Well, it certainly speaks to experience. No really, friendly advice, forgive me, but that sounds like both denial and projection on steroids.

SueN's picture
SueN 2 years 16 weeks ago

I don't think there was one day during Trump's presidency when I did not fear what bad things he might do that day. He may be out of the White House but he was enabled by the Republicans in Congress, by billionaires and big corporations, and by right wing media, and millions of Americans have been indoctrinated to follow him and them. He and they must absolutely not be fogiven or forgotten, much as I would like to be able to turn to more positive things. That will have to wait until those responsible are held accountable.

The attempted coup at the Capitol was not imaginary. The withholding of relief for workers and small businesses was not imaginary. The deliberate neglect of COVID was not imaginary. The fight against sociopaths in power must not cease.

Legend 2 years 16 weeks ago

Wow. they get it in the United Kindom and 74 million do not understand it here.

Where did 20 million vaccine dose disappear to? My guess Israel. Jared?

Thom's Blog Is On the Move

Hello All

Thom's blog in this space and moving to a new home.

Please follow us across to - this will be the only place going forward to read Thom's blog posts and articles.

From The Thom Hartmann Reader:
"Never one to shy away from the truth, Thom Hartmann’s collected works are inspiring, wise, and compelling. His work lights the way to a better America."
Van Jones, cofounder of and author of The Green Collar Economy
From The Thom Hartmann Reader:
"Right through the worst of the Bush years and into the present, Thom Hartmann has been one of the very few voices constantly willing to tell the truth. Rank him up there with Jon Stewart, Bill Moyers, and Paul Krugman for having the sheer persistent courage of his convictions."
Bill McKibben, author of Eaarth
From The Thom Hartmann Reader:
"Thom Hartmann channels the best of the American Founders with voice and pen. His deep attachment to a democratic civil society is just the medicine America needs."
Tom Hayden, author of The Long Sixties and director, Peace and Justice Resource Center.