This is a fulfillment of a prophesy by Karl Marx, the automated society of presumed time on our hands, only he thought it would come AFTER the revolution.
I worked in newspaper circulation and I was friendly with a delivery driver there. We were talking once about a recent layoff at our newspaper where the staff in the press room was cut in half due to improved technology. The drivers at our paper often talked of day that may come when the drivers' job would be eliminated by technology of driverless vehicles. Good union contracts of drivers makes for high labor costs and would be an incentive for newspaper owners to do that.
My friend said, "You can replace all the drivers, all the pressmen and everybody who works at the newspaper with machines. There's only one problem with that, machines don't buy newspapers."
That brings us to another prediction by Karl Marx which keeps fulfilling every so often - most recently in 2007. That is the "Theory of the Concentration of Wealth and the Pauperization of the Working Classes". It holds that capitalism will ultimately destroy itself with all the wealth falling into fewer and fewer hands.
Marx also held as central to his thesis that technology is the main determinant of the political economy of a society. Today nation states are obsolete and corporations become the governments of a new feudalusm because there is now technology that enables businesses owners to manage production from the other side of the world. How this will be fulfilled is yet to be seen.
Thom Hartmann and Paul Buchheit both are dumbfounded by what to do about the reality that tectonic shifts in the technologies of production and global downward pressure on wages is destroying jobs and devaluing the worth of labor. There solution: the State should step in a provide EVERY citizen a Minimum Guaranteed Income. This effectively means tax extract the production of those actually who are productive, whether through their labor or through their productive capital assets, which they OWN.
Wealth distribution assumes wealth creation, and productive capital (i.e., tools, machines, robotics, computerization, technological and systems advances and improved land uses), according to recent studies, accounts for almost 90 percent of productivity growth in the modern world. Thus, balanced growth in a market economy depends on incomes distributed through widespread individual ownership of productive capital, all non-human means of production. Without access to and the means to acquire productive capital, people cannot produce enough to purchase the production of others.
Most people on the planet have no legitimate ownership claim to, and have insufficient means to purchase, what technology’s phenomenal productive capacity can generate. On the other hand, the small minority of people who own and control most of the productive instruments of society end up producing more than they can humanly consume.
Both socialism and capitalism concentrate economic power at the top. It makes little difference that under capitalism the concentration is in private hands and under socialism the concentration is in the hands of the State.
What then would be a workable alternative economic model for moving toward a more free, more just and economically classless society?
The REAL solution is to restructure the underlying system, balancing the demands of participative and distributive justice by lifting institutional barriers that have historically separated owners from non-owners. This involves removing the roadblocks preventing people from participating fully in the economic process as both workers and owners.
The Just Third Way offers a just free market system that economically empowers all individuals and families through the democratization of money and credit for new production. Widespread citizen access to money power would create universal access to direct ownership of wealth-creating and income-producing capital.
We have a choice ! Scott and Helen Nearing laid the foundation in their book "Making of a Radical " Scott Nearing never endorsed violence or anarchy but rather a change in the way we think. I believe Scott and Helen Nearing had a sustainable and mentally healthy alternative to the technological nightmare we all find ourselves in currently. I believe it's a step in the right direction instead of a step backward. A society can enjoy life without all these APPS and prosper and be better and more successful and without batteries. Really ! our lifestyle is completely unsustainable. Machines and computers may be able to keep this up...but biology and humans cannot. We are currently beyond crazy.
Damned typos!
I think it was Lamarr Waldron who said on Thom's show that "socialism", as a term, is being rehabilitated among milleneals. He said that the hyperbolic use of it by Republicans to describe everything from Social Security to public education has caused them to react positively and even identify with the term.They say that if those things are "socialism" then they must be socialists because they are for all that.
Kend, why does it never penetrate with you that the debt is because of wilfull, reckless mismanagement, namely two wars kept off the books for 7 years by G.W. Bush, not by socialist policies - which we haven't had anyway.
RoseM481 -- That sounds like the repug solution. That is, let the churches take care of the poor. It has been tried all over the world, and always comes up short (according to Thom).
IRV -- You do realize that you have used numbers from BP to support some of your statements. To paraphrase you, Citigroup looks like a fairy godmother compared to BP.
I wish Thom would use the words "automation" and "leisure society" more often.
These words have been used for the last 50 or 60 years at least. People have weighed in for all those years for the best solution. In all those years, I never heard anyone suggest a basic minimum income. Before I go on, I need to say if the basic min income were on a ballot I would vote for it in an instant.
However, I prefer a solution that takes the marketplace back from the billionaires. A concept also known as labor unions and/or co-ops. Since Nancy Pelosi in 2009 was within a few votes of passing card check, I think that is the most viable solution.
how long until a new NATO sub base appears back at SITE ONE (SCOTLAND)? Sign said "got to have a membership card to get inside" ! Germany took in millions of east germans 20 something years ago and now look at its progress kicking and screaming all the way? the country that welcomes this mass of humanity into their country will be alot better for its act of kindness? many generations to come. these people are deeply distressed and not skill or clueless? America broke this and are now cherry picking refugees for 10k nazi rocket scientists coming out of MENA to fix it?
In the 80s we had Reagan/Thatcher. The antithesis would be Sanders/Corbyn. The tide is turning. The Populists are rising! Has our time finally come? You briefly mentioned the 100th Monkey theory this morning. I Recommend that you get Rupert Sheldrake on your show. He has a fascinating, and very science based, view on the 100th Monkey theory theory.
The 100th monkey story is often told and appears to support the idea of morphic resonance. However, I never use this myself because most of the versions of it that are in circulation have drifted a long way from the actual facts. It is then easy for sceptics to debunk. The original story appears in Lyall Watson's book Lifetide, where he describes research on Japanese macaque monkeys, which have been studied intensively for more than four decades in a number of wild colonies. In 1952, a researcher first provided monkeys in one colony on the island of Koshima with sweet potatoes, which were thrown onto the beach and hence were covered with sand. One of the monkeys, an 18-month-old female, called Imo, solved the problem of the sand on the potatoes by carrying them down to a stream and washing them before feeding. This new form of behaviour spread through the colony. By 1958 all the juveniles were washing dirty food and some of the adults learned to do so by imitating their children. Watson goes on to say: "Then something extraordinary took place. The details up to this point in the study are clear, but one has to gather the rest of the story from personal anecdotes and bits of folklore among primate researchers, because most of them are still not quite sure what happened. ..... I am forced to improvise the details, but as near as I can tell, this is what seems to have happened." Watson then tells the original version of the 100th monkey story, making it clear that this is not literally what happened but a kind of dramatisation of it: "In the autumn of that year [1958] an unspecified number of monkeys on Koshima were washing sweet potatoes in the sea, because Imo had made the further discovery that salt water not only cleaned the food but gave it an interesting new flavour. Let us say, for arguments sake, that the number was 99 and that at eleven o'clock on the Tuesday morning, one further convert was added to the fold in the usual way. But the addition of the 100th monkey apparently carried the number across some sort of threshold, pushing it through a kind of critical mass, because by that evening almost everyone in the colony was doing it. Not only that, but the habit seems to have jumped natural barriers to have appeared spontaneously, like glycerine crystals in sealed laboratory jars, in colonies in other islands and on the mainland in a troop at Takasakiama." This story has been repeated by all sorts of new age speakers and writers, mutating as it is retold. I think that the observations to which Watson was referring do show something like morphic resonance, but exaggerated versions of the story often bear little relation to what really happened. I myself prefer the example of rats that learned a new trick in one laboratory (Harvard) and later groups of rats in other laboratories, in Scotland and Australia that learned the new trick quicker. The details are given in my book A New Science of Life chapter 11.
Good blog and comments, but I have one correction. Ghandi apparently never said the quote in the beginning of the post. The apparent source of the quote was a trade unionist in the U.S. named Nicholas Klein, in 1918.
Mr Siegelman sounds very selfless and seems sincerely concerned with the welfare, education and future of fellow inmates. He wanted to talk about others and legislation that could help imprisoned individuals. I truly would love to see him pardoned in the future.
His ending comment on a 2010 ruling about citizens not having the right to not be framed is appalling and certainly it has to be unconstitutional. I'm in shock about this one, (it's comparable to the Patriot Act and/or NDAA's right for indefinite detainment, without charge or right to council), and I will be interested in hearing Mr Siegelman expound on this topic with you soon.
Kilo bang on. Is Bernie isn't a Socialist what is. Interesting how politics is changing. Poeple are truly sick of the same old crap. The left is moving far left and the right moving even further right. Sanders and Trump leading in the poles. Who would have thought. My question is can America aford all the promises Bernie is making? After all your current government has racked up almost ten trillion in debt in the last seven years.
Bernie is a socialist. What's the big deal? Bernie calls himself a socialist. He belongs to the Democratic Socialist Party. Read their website. They are socialists.
One more thing, until Bernie declares himself a democrat, he will not run as a democrat. Do you really believe the Democrat Party is going to let a self declared Independent (socialist) run for President under the Democrat banner?.
If you want, an hdmi cable plugged into your laptop and your flatscreen allows great content that can be shared with friends. My daughter hooked her spotify through the screen mounted on her bedroom wall, too. Then Netflix, Youtube, or whatever. No tv network propaganda at all, just information and entertainment.
Cyber Ghost is a VPN that acts as an anonymiser, and offers access to regional programming locked out of normal DNS servers and locations.
There are other VPNs, 'Hide my ass' is one I remember when I was searching.
This is a fulfillment of a prophesy by Karl Marx, the automated society of presumed time on our hands, only he thought it would come AFTER the revolution.
I worked in newspaper circulation and I was friendly with a delivery driver there. We were talking once about a recent layoff at our newspaper where the staff in the press room was cut in half due to improved technology. The drivers at our paper often talked of day that may come when the drivers' job would be eliminated by technology of driverless vehicles. Good union contracts of drivers makes for high labor costs and would be an incentive for newspaper owners to do that.
My friend said, "You can replace all the drivers, all the pressmen and everybody who works at the newspaper with machines. There's only one problem with that, machines don't buy newspapers."
That brings us to another prediction by Karl Marx which keeps fulfilling every so often - most recently in 2007. That is the "Theory of the Concentration of Wealth and the Pauperization of the Working Classes". It holds that capitalism will ultimately destroy itself with all the wealth falling into fewer and fewer hands.
Marx also held as central to his thesis that technology is the main determinant of the political economy of a society. Today nation states are obsolete and corporations become the governments of a new feudalusm because there is now technology that enables businesses owners to manage production from the other side of the world. How this will be fulfilled is yet to be seen.
Alaska has a well tested system to distribute the oil wealth:
http://usbig.net/alaskablog/about-the-alaska-dividend/
However, better would be a WPA program like Roosevelt ran.
1---more likely to get funded by Repubs.
2---regular workers will feel everyone is contributing as best they can.
(not collecting check and staying stoned).
However, any program to spread the wealth will need a national ID card.
Without that, there is no discussion.
ct
Thom Hartmann and Paul Buchheit both are dumbfounded by what to do about the reality that tectonic shifts in the technologies of production and global downward pressure on wages is destroying jobs and devaluing the worth of labor. There solution: the State should step in a provide EVERY citizen a Minimum Guaranteed Income. This effectively means tax extract the production of those actually who are productive, whether through their labor or through their productive capital assets, which they OWN.
Wealth distribution assumes wealth creation, and productive capital (i.e., tools, machines, robotics, computerization, technological and systems advances and improved land uses), according to recent studies, accounts for almost 90 percent of productivity growth in the modern world. Thus, balanced growth in a market economy depends on incomes distributed through widespread individual ownership of productive capital, all non-human means of production. Without access to and the means to acquire productive capital, people cannot produce enough to purchase the production of others.
Most people on the planet have no legitimate ownership claim to, and have insufficient means to purchase, what technology’s phenomenal productive capacity can generate. On the other hand, the small minority of people who own and control most of the productive instruments of society end up producing more than they can humanly consume.
Both socialism and capitalism concentrate economic power at the top. It makes little difference that under capitalism the concentration is in private hands and under socialism the concentration is in the hands of the State.
What then would be a workable alternative economic model for moving toward a more free, more just and economically classless society?
The REAL solution is to restructure the underlying system, balancing the demands of participative and distributive justice by lifting institutional barriers that have historically separated owners from non-owners. This involves removing the roadblocks preventing people from participating fully in the economic process as both workers and owners.
The Just Third Way offers a just free market system that economically empowers all individuals and families through the democratization of money and credit for new production. Widespread citizen access to money power would create universal access to direct ownership of wealth-creating and income-producing capital.
Hartmann and Buchheit should support the Agenda of The Just Third Way Movement at http://foreconomicjustice.org/?p=5797, http://www.cesj.org/resources/articles-index/the-just-third-way-basic-principles-of-economic-and-social-justice-by-norman-g-kurland/, http://www.cesj.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/jtw-graphicoverview-2013.pdf and http://www.cesj.org/resources/articles-index/the-just-third-way-a-new-vision-for-providing-hope-justice-and-economic-empowerment/.
We have a choice ! Scott and Helen Nearing laid the foundation in their book "Making of a Radical " Scott Nearing never endorsed violence or anarchy but rather a change in the way we think. I believe Scott and Helen Nearing had a sustainable and mentally healthy alternative to the technological nightmare we all find ourselves in currently. I believe it's a step in the right direction instead of a step backward. A society can enjoy life without all these APPS and prosper and be better and more successful and without batteries. Really ! our lifestyle is completely unsustainable. Machines and computers may be able to keep this up...but biology and humans cannot. We are currently beyond crazy.
Damned typos!
I think it was Lamarr Waldron who said on Thom's show that "socialism", as a term, is being rehabilitated among milleneals. He said that the hyperbolic use of it by Republicans to describe everything from Social Security to public education has caused them to react positively and even identify with the term.They say that if those things are "socialism" then they must be socialists because they are for all that.
Kend, why does it never penetrate with you that the debt is because of wilfull, reckless mismanagement, namely two wars kept off the books for 7 years by G.W. Bush, not by socialist policies - which we haven't had anyway.
KCRuger -- They grow corn for ethanol. I think you need to expand your idea to include areas that can be used for food production.
mjolnir -- I agree that I would become irrational if someone beat the crap out of me.
Mark S -- Do you think our dead meat will be usable by some species like cockroaches.
RoseM481 -- That sounds like the repug solution. That is, let the churches take care of the poor. It has been tried all over the world, and always comes up short (according to Thom).
IRV -- You do realize that you have used numbers from BP to support some of your statements. To paraphrase you, Citigroup looks like a fairy godmother compared to BP.
IRV -- Where do you get all the time to spend on the details of nuclear energy? Are you receiving any financial incentive?
I am working on a rebuttal of almost every single item on your defense of nuclear, but it takes lots of time.
I wish Thom would use the words "automation" and "leisure society" more often.
These words have been used for the last 50 or 60 years at least. People have weighed in for all those years for the best solution. In all those years, I never heard anyone suggest a basic minimum income. Before I go on, I need to say if the basic min income were on a ballot I would vote for it in an instant.
However, I prefer a solution that takes the marketplace back from the billionaires. A concept also known as labor unions and/or co-ops. Since Nancy Pelosi in 2009 was within a few votes of passing card check, I think that is the most viable solution.
Wow Thom! I posted the above before you did a whole segment on the 100th monkey!
how long until a new NATO sub base appears back at SITE ONE (SCOTLAND)? Sign said "got to have a membership card to get inside" ! Germany took in millions of east germans 20 something years ago and now look at its progress kicking and screaming all the way? the country that welcomes this mass of humanity into their country will be alot better for its act of kindness? many generations to come. these people are deeply distressed and not skill or clueless? America broke this and are now cherry picking refugees for 10k nazi rocket scientists coming out of MENA to fix it?
In the 80s we had Reagan/Thatcher. The antithesis would be Sanders/Corbyn. The tide is turning. The Populists are rising! Has our time finally come?
You briefly mentioned the 100th Monkey theory this morning. I Recommend that you get Rupert Sheldrake on your show. He has a fascinating, and very science based, view on the 100th Monkey theory theory.
From Rubert Sheldrake's website:
http://www.sheldrake.org/about-rupert-sheldrake/frequently-asked-questions
The 100th monkey story is often told and appears to support the idea of morphic resonance. However, I never use this myself because most of the versions of it that are in circulation have drifted a long way from the actual facts. It is then easy for sceptics to debunk.
The original story appears in Lyall Watson's book Lifetide, where he describes research on Japanese macaque monkeys, which have been studied intensively for more than four decades in a number of wild colonies. In 1952, a researcher first provided monkeys in one colony on the island of Koshima with sweet potatoes, which were thrown onto the beach and hence were covered with sand. One of the monkeys, an 18-month-old female, called Imo, solved the problem of the sand on the potatoes by carrying them down to a stream and washing them before feeding. This new form of behaviour spread through the colony. By 1958 all the juveniles were washing dirty food and some of the adults learned to do so by imitating their children.
Watson goes on to say: "Then something extraordinary took place. The details up to this point in the study are clear, but one has to gather the rest of the story from personal anecdotes and bits of folklore among primate researchers, because most of them are still not quite sure what happened. ..... I am forced to improvise the details, but as near as I can tell, this is what seems to have happened." Watson then tells the original version of the 100th monkey story, making it clear that this is not literally what happened but a kind of dramatisation of it:
"In the autumn of that year [1958] an unspecified number of monkeys on Koshima were washing sweet potatoes in the sea, because Imo had made the further discovery that salt water not only cleaned the food but gave it an interesting new flavour. Let us say, for arguments sake, that the number was 99 and that at eleven o'clock on the Tuesday morning, one further convert was added to the fold in the usual way. But the addition of the 100th monkey apparently carried the number across some sort of threshold, pushing it through a kind of critical mass, because by that evening almost everyone in the colony was doing it. Not only that, but the habit seems to have jumped natural barriers to have appeared spontaneously, like glycerine crystals in sealed laboratory jars, in colonies in other islands and on the mainland in a troop at Takasakiama."
This story has been repeated by all sorts of new age speakers and writers, mutating as it is retold. I think that the observations to which Watson was referring do show something like morphic resonance, but exaggerated versions of the story often bear little relation to what really happened. I myself prefer the example of rats that learned a new trick in one laboratory (Harvard) and later groups of rats in other laboratories, in Scotland and Australia that learned the new trick quicker. The details are given in my book A New Science of Life chapter 11.
Reply to #11: Kend, you crack me up.
Hello Mark. Fancy running into you over here. :)
Good blog and comments, but I have one correction. Ghandi apparently never said the quote in the beginning of the post. The apparent source of the quote was a trade unionist in the U.S. named Nicholas Klein, in 1918.
http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Politics/2011/0603/Political-misquotes-The-10-most-famous-things-never-actually-said/First-they-ignore-you.-Then-they-laugh-at-you.-Then-they-attack-you.-Then-you-win.-Mohandas-Gandhi
I'm in total agreement with the Colonel! His words were spot on. Cheney and others should be behind bars.
Mr Siegelman sounds very selfless and seems sincerely concerned with the welfare, education and future of fellow inmates. He wanted to talk about others and legislation that could help imprisoned individuals. I truly would love to see him pardoned in the future.
His ending comment on a 2010 ruling about citizens not having the right to not be framed is appalling and certainly it has to be unconstitutional. I'm in shock about this one, (it's comparable to the Patriot Act and/or NDAA's right for indefinite detainment, without charge or right to council), and I will be interested in hearing Mr Siegelman expound on this topic with you soon.
Justice isn't real huh?
Alice could you say something nasty to me just to remind of of the good old days. LOL
Kilo bang on. Is Bernie isn't a Socialist what is. Interesting how politics is changing. Poeple are truly sick of the same old crap. The left is moving far left and the right moving even further right. Sanders and Trump leading in the poles. Who would have thought. My question is can America aford all the promises Bernie is making? After all your current government has racked up almost ten trillion in debt in the last seven years.
Reply #4
Bernie is a socialist. What's the big deal? Bernie calls himself a socialist. He belongs to the Democratic Socialist Party. Read their website. They are socialists.
One more thing, until Bernie declares himself a democrat, he will not run as a democrat. Do you really believe the Democrat Party is going to let a self declared Independent (socialist) run for President under the Democrat banner?.
Adios to Rick Perry
{a coupla limericks}
Adios to you, Rick Perry.
We’re MUCH more, MUCH more merry
when ambitions you bury
on the Texican prairy.
When inert, you’re not so scary.
. . . .
May all of the Prez-seeking Right
follow your suit and take flight, -
- and make our day bright
with {smarter} sharper light
so that America dudn’t suffer y’awl’s blight.
===============================
If you want, an hdmi cable plugged into your laptop and your flatscreen allows great content that can be shared with friends. My daughter hooked her spotify through the screen mounted on her bedroom wall, too. Then Netflix, Youtube, or whatever. No tv network propaganda at all, just information and entertainment.
Cyber Ghost is a VPN that acts as an anonymiser, and offers access to regional programming locked out of normal DNS servers and locations.
There are other VPNs, 'Hide my ass' is one I remember when I was searching.