Recent comments

  • Chelsea Manning   11 years 41 weeks ago

    David Abbot ~ I agree with everything you said. Especially the part about the bravery of Chelsea Manning. Unbelievable! Perhaps it is just the way some of us are wired. All or nothing! It is far better to leave the world at a young age with a taste of what it should be than to live it the world the way it is disgusted with every part of it. Very Christ like. With people like Manning and Snowden in the world it becomes far easier to believe in someone like Jesus Christ. Just look at the future that has been inspired by Jesus in these two people. The faith is spreading beyond the control of its opposition. Keep the faith!

  • Has MLK's dream been realized?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    Personally I believe the dream MLK envisioned has been achieved. Why? Because this dream is more than just social change; it is, in fact, personal change. We must realize this dream of equality first within our own hearts. When we have accepted that than we can expect no less from society. The change begins within each and every one of us. As we accept the change and universal equality within us, we express that change in the world around us. Therefore, accept universal equality first within your own heart, and the dream of MLK will be real and true to you. That is the first and final triumph in his dream. That is the only way to change the world. Be the change that you want to see in others.

  • Will Congress accomplish anything when they return next month?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    The more they stall, the more people will feel frustrated. Let's hope the footdragging works in favor of progressives.

  • Will Congress accomplish anything when they return next month?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    Republicans just don't know how to govern. They are to worried about the black president whom has more brain power then all of them put togather.

  • Has MLK's dream been realized?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    MLK was concerned with economic justice and equality for ALL people not just people of color and he started the Poor Peoples' Campaign. His mission and legacy was betrayed in this way more than any other. Particularly so because racial "diversity" and a very capitalist assimilation of African American society into mainstream American society (which started sometime after King and continues now) was used to divert attention away from economic inequality.

    That is partly because in the care free, middle class U.S. economy of the '60s we were a middle class society. Labor was strong (and corrupt - it had become part of the problem, a strong impediment to social change and the redistribution of power) and poverty was almost non existant. What poverty there was was largely race based, i.e., it was largely the result of racial dicrimination. For this reason the social justice movements of the '60s took up issues of racial rather than economic - or class - justice and the idea of a class struggle never really became popularized, hip or fashionable in the U.S.. Labor's corruption led to its demonization and ultimate decline lending itself to the Right's campaign against it and the suppression of class consciousness.

    Meanwhile the big bussiness media, in service of the Right's campaign, diverted attention from economic injustice by cynically exploiting racial issues pointing to "diversification" of the elite sectors of society. We now have Clarence Thomas, Condoleeza Rice and Barrack Obamma so everything's right with the world. We're "post racial".

    Henry Louis Gates Jr., an African American Harvard professor, in his book Beyond Race, argues that class is a greater divider than race in current society (don't know what he might say now after his famous encounter with the police when he locked himself out of his his house and he they mistook him for a burglar). That's kind of a traditional Marxist view and kind of likeThom's "Billionairistan" thesis. In contemporary U.S. society it is easier to have a friend - or even to marry someone - of another race than of another class.

    For further reading I recommend The Trouble with Diversity: How We Learned to Love Identity and Ignore Inequality by Walter Benn Michaels, Henry Holt and Company, 2006.

  • The Lost People   11 years 41 weeks ago

    'The Lost People' should be on page one.

  • Does Obama's student debt plan go far enough?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    The Twain Report

    All The News That Mark Twain Says He Would Report If He Was Alive Today

    8-24-2013

    When Goldman Sachs Banker Jason Lee was Arrested yesterday for raping a woman in his Hamptons rental house in the presence of other guests, locals were quick to rally to his defense.

    "Oh, you can't really call that rape," said East Hamptons Rolls Royce dealer Humbert Smythington III. "For God's sake, the man is brilliant- he has a doctorate in international finance and he is on the short list to become the Dominique Strauss-Kahn Professor of Economics at Harvard School of Finance. Anyone with any education at all knows that Mr. Lee was simply applying well-proven economics principles to interpersonal relationships."

    "My children," said Rory Cheerful McBlockkopf III, bishop of the Hamptons Catholic Diocese, "have we strayed so far from God's teachings as revealed in Ayn Rand's sacred scriptures, that a man who simply finds a resource and avails himself of said resource, can be arrested and charged with a crime? And more to the point, how can a man who only last week gave me a $20,000 box of Cuban cigar be guilty of anything? God damn it, I'm the bishop around here, and I very specifically gave Mr. Lee a dispensation for any rape that he would commit in the next week and a half, with an option to give me another box of cigars and extend the dispensation to cover a full month."

    The Twain Report is taking up a collection so our editor- not a wealthy man by any measure- can get a dispensation just in case he gets a parking ticket or thinks an unkind thought. Please send your donations of at least $50,000 in cash, to:

    The Bribe God for the Twain Report Fund

    C/O H. E. Bishop RC McBlockkopf

    Bank of America building

    East Hamptons, NY

  • Buying congress people isn't paying off for Big Business.   11 years 41 weeks ago

    I don't know whether he was telling me the truth (because he's an alcoholic and drug user and has some strange values...), but a Mexican guy I know, told me that Mexico does not have free health care for the poor or middle classes, unless you go to an emergency room in which case they have to treat you.

  • Chelsea Manning   11 years 41 weeks ago

    chuckle8 ~ You are welcome for the discussion. By the way, I did some research of my own. Negative rights are not necessarily a bad thing. They are defined as rights that protect people from the actions of other people. Definition per wikipedia:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_rights

    On Negative Rights vs Positive Rights:

    Quote wikipedia:Under the theory of positive and negative rights, a negative right is a right not to be subjected to an action of another person or group—a government, for example—usually in the form of abuse or coercion. A positive right is a right to be subjected to an action of another person or group. In theory, a negative right forbids others from acting against the right holder, while a positive right obligates others to act with respect to the right holder. In the framework of the Kantian categorical imperative, negative rights can be associated with perfect duties while positive rights can be connected to imperfect duties.[citation needed]

    Belief in a distinction between positive and negative rights is usually maintained, or emphasized, by libertarians, who believe that positive rights do not exist until they are created by contract. The United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights lists both positive and negative rights (but does not identify them as such). The constitutions of most liberal democracies guarantee negative rights, but not all include positive rights. Nevertheless, positive rights are often guaranteed by other laws, and the majority of liberal democracies provide their citizens with publicly funded education, health care, social security and unemployment benefits.

    Negative rights tend to protect individuals from bullies like corporations, religious institutions, mafia, unfair employers and each other. Negative here is a noun and not an adjective. I admit very confusing, but nothing to be wary of.

  • Has MLK's dream been realized?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    Oops, forgot this one: Cencorship spreads like a disease

    http://www.wired.com/opinion/2013/08/ap_mers/

  • Has MLK's dream been realized?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    Links for today:

    The NSA is cracking the UN's video confrencing encryptin all after condemming China for doing it

    http://rt.com/news/nsa-us-un-germany-snowden-964/

    Teens actually starting to care about online privacy

    http://yro.slashdot.org/story/13/08/24/2017201/teens-actually-care-about...

    Cookieless tracking being done now via ETags

    http://lucb1e.com/rp/cookielesscookies/

    Fukushima worse then reported

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-23779561

    The secret cleanup of Soviet nuclear test site

    http://news.slashdot.org/story/13/08/20/1738213/the-secret-effort-to-cle...

    GMO rice passing on it's roundup ready genes to weeds

    http://science.slashdot.org/story/13/08/19/221202/gm-rice-passes-unexpec...

    The next level of corporate explotation of the public

    http://yro.slashdot.org/story/13/08/17/0354202/the-next-frontier-of-cons...

  • Does Obama's student debt plan go far enough?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    Flopot ~ A Day of Jubilee is an excellent suggestion. I certainly second that idea! Your anthem suggestion is both sophisticated and appropriate; but, might not carry the enthusiasm that one might hope for. Might I suggest "We Ain't Gonna Take It" by Twisted Sister. Oh, well, let the masses decide on the music--just give me the Jubilee.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4xmckWVPRaI

    On the count of chemical weapons, the interference in the Iraq/Iran war by President Ronald Wilson (666) Reagan and the State Department is well recorded. I remember reading about it at the time through articles in the local Guardian. It was wise of you to bring that up, along with a plethora of citations to further the argument that history tends to repeat itself. In this case, when war criminals get away with a crime they always come back to repeat it and out do themselves. It's almost like they can't help themselves. For me, and many of my generation, the announcement that one side in Syria is using chemical weapons against the other side when the Pentagon is itching to get involved only brings back feelings of deja vu. The only question I really have is how did we manage to supply the "bad" guys with the chemicals this time? Did we trick Russia, Italy or maybe use Chile again. Whether or not we did it seems like a naive question to ask, doesn't it? Yet by and large most Americans you will meet will act shocked and disbelieving were you even to suggest such a notion. In either case the use of these weapons will facilitate the excuse to have our way with Syria.

    PS By the way, don't discount your idea of selecting Congressmen by lot. I think that is an excellent suggestion. Let go with it!

    PPS We need a UN that has some bite and some balls.

  • Chelsea Manning   11 years 41 weeks ago

    DAnneMarc -- Thank you for discussing the topic. I will continue to research the subject since I cannot think of a more important topic than the will of the people to determine the rules we live by. I think the words "We the People" in the preamble are more important than anything else in the constitution or its amendents.

  • Has MLK's dream been realized?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    There has been a corporate coup, and we have lost! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C8H0ty327o0

  • Has MLK's dream been realized?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    The dream realized after the murder of MLK, JFK & RFK is our current nightmare. The nexus of power that Eisenhower warned against took control by the murder of the greatest leaders of that generation. We still live with the consequences of that coup d'etat.

    Live the dream...

    Yes we can...

  • Does Obama's student debt plan go far enough?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    Time for a democratic jubilee - cancel the debts of the people and cancel the ongoing bailouts of the TBTF corporations.

    Here's an appropriate anthem...

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQD5zX4kOsE

    After the Day of Jubilee then break-up the corporations and start a democratic reform of the US system, e.g. selecting Congressmen by lot, like selecting a jury. Well, maybe that's too radical but it worked in Ancient Athens! An Athenian from the 5th Century BC would laugh at our oligarchic systems, "Hah! Democratic? I think not but Sparta would be impressed".

    PS The US encouraged Saddam Hussein to use chemical weapons on Iran during the Iran - Iraq War.

    http://rt.com/news/chemical-weapons-iran-iraq-980/

    PPS Donald Rumsfeld helped the Dictator purchase chemical weapons and shook the hand of the dictator

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-153210/Rumsfeld-helped-Iraq-chem...

    http://pilgrimakimbo.files.wordpress.com/2007/01/rummy-and-sadam.jpg

    PPPS Remember it is all about corporate control - the US is now a corporate dictatorship or didn't you get the memo?

    http://www.amazon.co.uk/Democracy-Incorporated-Managed-Inverted-Totalita...

  • Chelsea Manning   11 years 41 weeks ago

    Palindromedary, as uncomfortable as you- as a straight person- are with the subject of transgender medication/surgery, imagine how uncomfortable it could be for a man to stand up in today's homophobic America (and as if that wasn't enough, he makes his stand in a military prison, which is an even more frantically homophobic environment), and say that in his heart he has always been a woman, knowing that hundreds of millions of people all over the world will hear his statement. I was already incredibly impressed with Manning's courage before this, but now even more so.

    And yet, similar to you, I feel personally uncomfortable around people like Manning. What has changed in recent years, however, is that- like you- I freely admit to the discomfort I feel, and I don't try to justify or excuse it. I will know that I have made significant progress when I feel the same toward transgender people as I do toward everyone else.

    A Chinese doctor told me, "Everything in this universe is a direct result of the interaction of yin and yang. Most women are more yin than most men, but some women are very yang. And most men are more yang than most women, but some men are very yin. Sometimes these differences play out in the sexual arena, but even when they do, it's still just yin and yang."

    As an environmentalist, I would dearly love to see all hormone-disrupting chemicals banned, because they make an already complex and difficult situation, more complex and more difficult to understand clearly.

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday August 13th, 2013   11 years 41 weeks ago

    Agree that Republicans cheated in 2010... When will democrats fight back..... President Obamas biggest mistake IMO once he won election was not investigation the Bush administration over Iraq and holding them responsible

  • Chelsea Manning   11 years 41 weeks ago

    chuckle8 ~ Very well! At this time I feel certain that you are confusing apples and oranges. The founding fathers did perceive the common people as unable to participate in Government due to lack of education and information. They were right in many respects. Despite the current electronic information age coupled with free public education for everyone a very serious argument can still be made that the 'commoners' are not educated enough to participate in governmental decisions. However, that is not the argument at hand.

    The argument at had is whether or not We the People are deserving of the Bill of Rights. That is another argument altogether. Lets stick to that one. In that respect I must assert that the intent of the founding fathers was beyond a reasonable doubt to insure that every aspect of the Bill of Rights be applied to every American. In fact, despite the fact that African Americans were denied such rights at the time the Bill of Rights was written, I am certain beyond a reasonable doubt that they too were intended to be covered by these rights as well. The founding fathers simply wrote what they perceived to be the best plan for everyone and silently decided to let future generations figure it out.

    As far as "negative rights" are concerned, I am certain this a red herring created by a select few to confuse the general masses into accepting the concept that human rights are inherently bad and don't serve the common good. In this respect I have to say without any hesitation that the entire concept of "negative rights" is a bogus attempt to attack the Constitution by the 1%. You've stated that this concept comes from the Obama Administration and Thom Hartmann and yet have provided no reference, quotes, or evidence whatsoever. You've taken a term completely out of context without any definition. Without such sources this subject is merely hearsay and completely dead in the water.

    These "negative rights" as YOU call them should be called "Super Rights." They should never be challenged by any form of our legislative system. When elected all legislators from Congress to the Executive branch swear an oath to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States. That oath leaves no room for tampering with any part of our fundamental Constitution--including The Bill of Rights. It is The Bill of Rights first and foremost that must survive any legislative actions. It is possible that the current President is attacking The Bill of Rights because he certainly has demonstrated little intent on following through with his oath of office. However, Thom Hartmann is another story altogether. He has sworn no oath of any kind and has nothing to gain from treason. Perhaps he mentioned some ridiculous catch phrase the Administration is or has attempted to throw out; but, I feel confident that he is not promoting such a malicious unconstitutional agenda. If you feel he is, please provide your links and quotes. Otherwise, I am through with this topic. Please excuse me; but, I must move on to bigger, better and more tangible topics. See you next week.

  • Should the U.S. Military Pay for Chelsea Manning’s Hormone Pills?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    no.........

  • Chelsea Manning   11 years 41 weeks ago
    Quote David Abbot:
    Without people like Manning, America would just be another cheap-shot dictatorship. Manning should receive the Congressional Medal of Honor and a public apology, be given several million dollars for her service to America, and have a national holiday named after her.

    I sure agree with you there! And you are right...I really don't know anything about transgender people...although I do have acquaintances who are gay. And as a straight person, I am not really very comfortable about the subject.

  • Should every federal building have solar panels?   11 years 41 weeks ago

    arky: what is the German program. (Although it sounds like a cold day in hell before we'd get something like whatever you are advocating.)

  • Chelsea Manning   11 years 41 weeks ago

    DAnneMarc --- Noboby ever accused me of clarifying anything. If the "Bill of Rights" were as you describe neither Thom or Obama would call them negative. With my sophomoric understanding of history, I think when our country started, every other country in western civilization was run by the 1% or less. It was the opinion of the rest of the world that if the 99% were running government it would not work because they would take all the goodies for themselves and there would be no productionof value. This is the currect view of Fox News when they talk about the 47%. I think some of this view rubbed off on our founders. They wanted to protect certain rights from the democratic process of the simple majority and require a super majority. Remember all my discussion is trying to determine why Thom and Obama call them negative rights. I want to restate that all our liberty flows from we the people deciding laws based on a simple majority.

    I used to listen to Thom on my way to work -- a 10 minute drive. I missed a lot. When I retired I listened while walking at the beach for 2 hours. I heard a lot more. Then, Thom left LA and I subscribed to his podcasts. Podcasts have no commercials, so during a 2 hour walk I can hear everything he says. Of the 60 hours a month of Thom I would say he mentions "negative rights" for 10 seconds.

  • Buying congress people isn't paying off for Big Business.   11 years 41 weeks ago

    Even if the police had not wanted to execute Dorner for killing police, the last thing they and our government wanted, was Dorner testifying in court about what he saw the police doing to black people, so they had two non-negotiable reasons for wanting to execute him.

  • Chelsea Manning   11 years 41 weeks ago

    Palindromedary, I have to disagree with you in both general terms and in the specific case of Manning.

    Sex is an incredibly complex issue, made even more so by shame, fear, transference, and ignorance of what other people are going through in their own hearts as they come to terms with their own sexuality. You quoted the American psychiatric association, which is a bunch of highly educated but still fallible people who, as a group have made massive mistakes. A cousin of mine was committed to one of the largest state-run mental institutions in the state of Washington, where the psychiatrists and nurses used drugs, physical restraint, starvation, deprivation of water, and other means to torture the inmates. Literally torture them. If you think One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest was bad, well, the reality of what they did to my cousin was worse. So if you want credibility for your position that people are not born with gender identity, I would prefer that you quote someone other than a psychiatric association. And even if you do quote some other "authority," at its root your attitude is still psychological xenophobia, because you are not transgender. The only way I could accept that you have an informed opinion as to whether it is necessary for Manning to get gender-change medical care, would be if you had spent many hours talking with a transexual person.

    And specifically as far as Manning goes, as you yourself said, she is a hero. She demonstrated astounding courage in revealing crimes that our government has committed. Without people like Manning, America would just be another cheap-shot dictatorship. Manning should receive the Congressional Medal of Honor and a public apology, be given several million dollars for her service to America, and have a national holiday named after her.

    Our government- including Obama!- insists on spending at least $50,000 a year for Manning to be in prison. There's your waste of money, right there. Transgender medical care costs almost nothing compared to that, and it's the least that Manning should receive from her ungrateful government.

ADHD: Hunter in a Farmer's World

Thom Hartmann has written a dozen books covering ADD / ADHD - Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder.

Join Thom for his new twice-weekly email newsletters on ADHD, whether it affects you or a member of your family.

Thom's Blog Is On the Move

Hello All

Thom's blog in this space and moving to a new home.

Please follow us across to hartmannreport.com - this will be the only place going forward to read Thom's blog posts and articles.