@all commenters, the key for the Catholic Church to exist and to be viable will be whether or not the priests can marry. Without married priests membership will diminish substantially. The Catholic Church will still have some members but by 2080 its members will meet in basements and in the back alleys.
Please remember that the face of the Catholic Church is not the Catholic Mafia Five in the U. S. Supreme Court. A true Catholic is a true Christian and a disciple of Jesus Christ of Nazareth.
Does the ressurection of Jesus matter? If you believe in his teachings, do you really need him to be the son of God? What if Jesus slipped into a comma on the cross and he revived three days later, would that render his revelations to us impotent or would they remain important?
@Zero G, shortly after I encountered a massive heart attack, I read five books about the historical Jesus. The authors looked at Jesus' life as a puzzle that needed to fill in the missing parts. More and more evidence is proving that Jesus did live and that He was crucified. What will be very difficult to prove is Jesus' Resurrection. We must remember that faith is something we can neither prove nor disprove.
awww rladlof there you go again siting facts in the face of right wing BS. Don't you know that the past is there to be re-molded as seen fit by any right winger and the Texas School board?
@Gerald, can't disagree with that, without Vatican II I wonder if the church still be as strong as it is. It was far too rigid, Vatican II brought it flexibility. As an organization, it has chosen to sweep a lot of crap under the carpet, its still lead by conservatives, as it has been since Roman times. Its powerful and it attracts ambitious and corrupt people.
John Paul II said that he failed to speak out more against the assassination of Archbishop Oscar Romero.
Archbishop Oscar Romero
At one a.m. on November 16, 1989, 26 soldiers, 19 of them trained at the U.S. Army School of the Americas at Fort Benning, Georgia, stormed a Jesuit community in San Salvador, El Salvador. They killed six Jesuits and destroyed the house, word processors, Bibles, and filing cabinets. They also killed the cook and her daughter.
The deaths stunned the world. These good people were advocating the end of the brutal war within El Salvador and the daily $1.3 million in U.S. military aid that has funded the war. These people were killed because they were speaking out on behalf of the poor and oppressed. They had encouraged negotiations between the government and the rebel forces as well as the U.S. embassy. They had preached the gospel and comforted the poor and they paid the price.
Archbishop Romero was a champion for the poor, oppressed, and justice. Archbishop Romero was assassinated in 1980 and the people who loved him picked up his works of solidarity, peacemaking, and truth-telling. Since 1980 countless thousands of people in El Salvador have joined Oscar Romero in martyrdom. Romero’s life gave strength to the Jesuits. Since 1980, despite their most brutal efforts, the government and soldiers had one great problem: Romero, like Christ, refused to stay dead.
What the Salvadoran and U.S. government death squads did not know was that bullets cannot kill the spirit. They killed the bodies of 75,000 Salvadoran martyrs but they could not kill their spirits.
Perhaps the purveyors of death are beginning to learn a basic Christian lesson. CHRISTIANITY MAINTANS THAT THOSE WHO LOVE LIFE AND LIVE A LIFE OF LOVE, LIVE ON IN THE LOVE OF OTHERS. We Christians call this great truth, resurrection, the eternal spirit of nonviolent, revolutionary love that insists on justice and peace. It grows in the human community of love and truth that side with the poor in the nonviolent struggle for justice. Whoever dies in that nonviolent struggle lives on in the spirit of those who take up the struggle anew. Someone always picks up where the martyr leaves off. The spirit of love and truth lives on, the coming of God’s reign of justice and nonviolence gets closer and closer. Peace and justice become reality. Such is the lesson of martyrdom, the practice of resurrection, the essence of Christian love.
ALTHOUGH THE MUSLIMS ARE NOT CHRISTIANS, THEY, TOO, MAY HAVE TAKEN UP THE SPIRIT OF CHRISTIANITY IN A WRONG AND AN IMMORAL WAR IN IRAQ.
Oscar Romero lived and died in that nonviolent struggle for justice. His life message was a call to conversion, solidarity with the poor, a speaking of truth to power. He proclaimed life when the system around him demanded death. He announced peace when the government and rebels waged war. He exuded hope when despair ruled the day. The message of the Christian community today is as dangerous as the message of Romero: Jesus lives! The Salvadoran death squads, the Pentagon, and the U.S war makers know it too: Romero lives! The nonviolent struggle for justice continues.
@Quark, I think that there is a lot to be said for non-violent resistance. It's not going to stop the tank every time you stand in front of it, but when the story, photo or video is spread, more and more people find the courage to stand up and say I'm not going to take it any more. Whereas you see a crowd of people throwing rocks and bottles at riot police, you may sympathize with their cause, but somewhere in the back of your mind you know their asking to get the crap kicked out of them, and you wonder if its really worthwhile to put your neck on the line with them. It just seems to me that in the long run, the common person wishes to avoid violent conflict, but will happily stand peacefully and say "I don't support this or that". Am I wrong?
@Zero G, depriving persons of a means to sustain themselves is similar to torture and/or terrorism. G. K. Chesterton said that there were people who were also slaves working for slave wages.
Christ, MLK and others used nonviolent protest throughout history. I wonder if the message they gave was meant for their fellow men more than for the authorities.
Thom, the Catholic Church does have annulment. Annulments are granted to marriages that were entered under a pretense of loving the person. Some persons cannot hold true to a contract and a commitment, such as the adultery, drug addicts, alcoholics a spouse is gay or a lesbian, etc. These are some examples. In annuled marriages a person can remarry in the Catholic Church. In this specific area the Church has matured.
I remain convinced of this though, hoarding wealth is violence to the whole. Depriving persons of the means to sustain themselves is violence. Every bit as violent as killing them outright.
@Zero G. I understand. Its a tough, tough issue to deal with correct use of violence. Fighting back in Warsaw, was there really any other choice, even if it was ultimately futile for them to do so. Up to the last moment in the concentration camps many didn't know when or if they were about to be killed, what they did know was that the slightest resistance on the way was often answered with a bullet. Hard for an unarmed mass to do anything effective against men carrying submachine guns. Really its a moot point, by the time people were being rounded up, they had already been disarmed and for all intents and purposes shell shocked. The only chance for the fight against the racism to have been successful might have been in the '20's, prior to the NAZI's rise to power. The question then becomes would violent or non-violent resistance been the best tactic. Being that if violent tactics were employed it may have played more into the hands of the NAZI's propaganda, though on the other hand, non-violent gatherings may have become ripe targets. Its impossible for me to say what would have been the best way to go, but obviously the lesson we should learn from it, is by being divided and doing little to nothing results in further and further erosion of rights.
@all commenters, the key for the Catholic Church to exist and to be viable will be whether or not the priests can marry. Without married priests membership will diminish substantially. The Catholic Church will still have some members but by 2080 its members will meet in basements and in the back alleys.
Please remember that the face of the Catholic Church is not the Catholic Mafia Five in the U. S. Supreme Court. A true Catholic is a true Christian and a disciple of Jesus Christ of Nazareth.
Does the ressurection of Jesus matter? If you believe in his teachings, do you really need him to be the son of God? What if Jesus slipped into a comma on the cross and he revived three days later, would that render his revelations to us impotent or would they remain important?
@Zero G, shortly after I encountered a massive heart attack, I read five books about the historical Jesus. The authors looked at Jesus' life as a puzzle that needed to fill in the missing parts. More and more evidence is proving that Jesus did live and that He was crucified. What will be very difficult to prove is Jesus' Resurrection. We must remember that faith is something we can neither prove nor disprove.
@Zero G, can't say I have... conspiracy theory?
Anybody read David Yallop's In God's Name on the death of John Paul the First...
rladlof, next you're going to tell us, that it was a small article buried in the back of the rag.
N
awww rladlof there you go again siting facts in the face of right wing BS. Don't you know that the past is there to be re-molded as seen fit by any right winger and the Texas School board?
N
The LDS financing Prop Hate did not hit Newsweek until November 15th . . . Two weeks after the election.
@Gerald, can't disagree with that, without Vatican II I wonder if the church still be as strong as it is. It was far too rigid, Vatican II brought it flexibility. As an organization, it has chosen to sweep a lot of crap under the carpet, its still lead by conservatives, as it has been since Roman times. Its powerful and it attracts ambitious and corrupt people.
John Paul II said that he failed to speak out more against the assassination of Archbishop Oscar Romero.
Archbishop Oscar Romero
At one a.m. on November 16, 1989, 26 soldiers, 19 of them trained at the U.S. Army School of the Americas at Fort Benning, Georgia, stormed a Jesuit community in San Salvador, El Salvador. They killed six Jesuits and destroyed the house, word processors, Bibles, and filing cabinets. They also killed the cook and her daughter.
The deaths stunned the world. These good people were advocating the end of the brutal war within El Salvador and the daily $1.3 million in U.S. military aid that has funded the war. These people were killed because they were speaking out on behalf of the poor and oppressed. They had encouraged negotiations between the government and the rebel forces as well as the U.S. embassy. They had preached the gospel and comforted the poor and they paid the price.
Archbishop Romero was a champion for the poor, oppressed, and justice. Archbishop Romero was assassinated in 1980 and the people who loved him picked up his works of solidarity, peacemaking, and truth-telling. Since 1980 countless thousands of people in El Salvador have joined Oscar Romero in martyrdom. Romero’s life gave strength to the Jesuits. Since 1980, despite their most brutal efforts, the government and soldiers had one great problem: Romero, like Christ, refused to stay dead.
What the Salvadoran and U.S. government death squads did not know was that bullets cannot kill the spirit. They killed the bodies of 75,000 Salvadoran martyrs but they could not kill their spirits.
Perhaps the purveyors of death are beginning to learn a basic Christian lesson. CHRISTIANITY MAINTANS THAT THOSE WHO LOVE LIFE AND LIVE A LIFE OF LOVE, LIVE ON IN THE LOVE OF OTHERS. We Christians call this great truth, resurrection, the eternal spirit of nonviolent, revolutionary love that insists on justice and peace. It grows in the human community of love and truth that side with the poor in the nonviolent struggle for justice. Whoever dies in that nonviolent struggle lives on in the spirit of those who take up the struggle anew. Someone always picks up where the martyr leaves off. The spirit of love and truth lives on, the coming of God’s reign of justice and nonviolence gets closer and closer. Peace and justice become reality. Such is the lesson of martyrdom, the practice of resurrection, the essence of Christian love.
ALTHOUGH THE MUSLIMS ARE NOT CHRISTIANS, THEY, TOO, MAY HAVE TAKEN UP THE SPIRIT OF CHRISTIANITY IN A WRONG AND AN IMMORAL WAR IN IRAQ.
Oscar Romero lived and died in that nonviolent struggle for justice. His life message was a call to conversion, solidarity with the poor, a speaking of truth to power. He proclaimed life when the system around him demanded death. He announced peace when the government and rebels waged war. He exuded hope when despair ruled the day. The message of the Christian community today is as dangerous as the message of Romero: Jesus lives! The Salvadoran death squads, the Pentagon, and the U.S war makers know it too: Romero lives! The nonviolent struggle for justice continues.
@Quark,
The nature of the Historical Jesus is a matter of scholarly dispute:
Historical Jesus Theories
@Maxrot, there are Catholics who seek to turn back Vatican II. Vatican II was a step in the right direction for the people.
@Quark, I think that there is a lot to be said for non-violent resistance. It's not going to stop the tank every time you stand in front of it, but when the story, photo or video is spread, more and more people find the courage to stand up and say I'm not going to take it any more. Whereas you see a crowd of people throwing rocks and bottles at riot police, you may sympathize with their cause, but somewhere in the back of your mind you know their asking to get the crap kicked out of them, and you wonder if its really worthwhile to put your neck on the line with them. It just seems to me that in the long run, the common person wishes to avoid violent conflict, but will happily stand peacefully and say "I don't support this or that". Am I wrong?
N
@Zero G, depriving persons of a means to sustain themselves is similar to torture and/or terrorism. G. K. Chesterton said that there were people who were also slaves working for slave wages.
Harry and Zero G.,
Christ, MLK and others used nonviolent protest throughout history. I wonder if the message they gave was meant for their fellow men more than for the authorities.
Zero G. the love of money is a root of all evil eh?
N
Thom, the Catholic Church does have annulment. Annulments are granted to marriages that were entered under a pretense of loving the person. Some persons cannot hold true to a contract and a commitment, such as the adultery, drug addicts, alcoholics a spouse is gay or a lesbian, etc. These are some examples. In annuled marriages a person can remarry in the Catholic Church. In this specific area the Church has matured.
I remain convinced of this though, hoarding wealth is violence to the whole. Depriving persons of the means to sustain themselves is violence. Every bit as violent as killing them outright.
Thanks folks, tough brain workout today...
Harry,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mWNnK0MF0L8&feature=fvw
@Zero G. I understand. Its a tough, tough issue to deal with correct use of violence. Fighting back in Warsaw, was there really any other choice, even if it was ultimately futile for them to do so. Up to the last moment in the concentration camps many didn't know when or if they were about to be killed, what they did know was that the slightest resistance on the way was often answered with a bullet. Hard for an unarmed mass to do anything effective against men carrying submachine guns. Really its a moot point, by the time people were being rounded up, they had already been disarmed and for all intents and purposes shell shocked. The only chance for the fight against the racism to have been successful might have been in the '20's, prior to the NAZI's rise to power. The question then becomes would violent or non-violent resistance been the best tactic. Being that if violent tactics were employed it may have played more into the hands of the NAZI's propaganda, though on the other hand, non-violent gatherings may have become ripe targets. Its impossible for me to say what would have been the best way to go, but obviously the lesson we should learn from it, is by being divided and doing little to nothing results in further and further erosion of rights.
N
I've seen it written, that when asked about the Jews in Nazi Germany by George Orwell, Gandhi replied:
“All Jews should commit mass suicide!”
If true, and I don't know, but if...
Quark,
True enough that Gandhi got the British to quit India - would he have prevailed against the Germans?
@Moonbat: didn richard dawkins host the gong show, or some other quiz show? :)
The Greatest Show On Earth by Richard Dawkins is a must read for anyone that tries to intertwine religion with evolution.
I think the blue water is coconut flavored, like sno cones!