Recent comments

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    I have a DVD of a German film called "The Experiment" which also examined how peer pressure, stress and a lack of self-esteem turned otherwise "civilized" people into torturers or even killers in a prisoner/guard dynamic. "Lord of the Flies" is also another good portrait of how people act outside civilized norms. Or a typical American Western will do.

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    Thom, please stop saying unnecessary wars, say illegal wars. More from Ray McGovern, 27 year CIA analyst:

    Under Yoo's theories, "wartime president" Bush could do whatever he wanted, even if that meant ignoring Congress, the United Nations Charter, and the post-World War II Nuremberg Tribunal. Bush simply could brush aside prohibitions against aggressive war as he did by invading Iraq.

    At Nuremberg, chief U.S. prosecutor, Supreme Court Justice Robert H. Jackson, called a war of aggression "not only an international crime; it is the supreme international crime differing only from other war crimes in that it contains within itself the accumulated evil of the whole."

    Nuremberg prosecutors also didn't let off Nazi lawyers who gave Adolf Hitler "legal advice" on how he could violate international law. The Nazi lawyers, too, were prosecuted at Nuremberg, and many served long prison sentences.

    And Justice Jackson could not have been more explicit in insisting that the Nuremberg standard must apply equally to all.

    War crimes, he said, are "crimes whether the United States does them or whether Germany does them, and we are not prepared to lay down a rule of criminal conduct against others which we would not be willing to have invoked against us."
    more: http://www.commondreams.org/view/2010/03/16

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday March 16th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    Frank,

    I don't have statistical data on homeschooling, just a lot of anecdotal information from my work as a professional educator who has done academic evaulations of home-schooled students for the past 13 years.

    In Colorado, parents who want to homeschool their children must file a notice of intent with their local school district or an independent school each year, and every other year they must submit either standardized test scores or a letter from a qualified evaluator testifying that their children are making adequate academic progress, according to their abilities.

    In my experience, parents who have teaching credentials or higher education degrees do not necessarily make better teachers of their own children. In addition, I have found that even the most conservative homeschooling parents give their children lots of enrichment opportunities in their community--including field trips to scientific and cultural sites, classes offered by schools and other institutions, and interaction with other children in the community and in homeschooling support groups.

    There may be abuses of the system, as there are in all systems (including public schools who advance children without knowing whether or not they're really learning what have been taught), but there is accountability built into the laws which govern homeschooling in most states.

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    Yoo Besmirches Legacy of Jefferson
    by Ray McGovern

    Initially I was shocked at the thought of the University of Virginia welcoming former Justice Department lawyer John Yoo to the "Academical Village" founded by Thomas Jefferson.

    There was something very wrong about that picture. Was it not Mr. Jefferson who condemned tyrannical acts-including ones that fell far short of waterboarding-in the Declaration of Independence?

    But I have come around to the view that Yoo's visit on Friday could present a rich teaching moment for those of us Virginians who believe passionately in the highest ideals that Mr. Jefferson articulated so eloquently.

    Yoo's visit presents a unique opportunity for my own children - four of them UVA alumni - to convey the essence of The University to those of our eight grandchildren who already aspire to study there.

    A teaching moment like this does require us to look through the eyes and the spectacles of Mr. Jefferson and our country's other gutsy Founders who pledged to each other "our Lives, our Fortunes, and our sacred Honor" to rid tyranny from America's shores. We tend to forget that the outcome of that brazen battle for liberty was far from assured when that vow was attached as the closing line of the Declaration of Independence in July 1776.
    more: http://www.commondreams.org/view/2010/03/16

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    woops- I left this off, the name of the bill is HR 4789, the Public Option Act.

    So to summarize
    1. Call Congress and ask them to co-sponsor HR 4789, the Public Option Act
    2. post results at WeWantMedicare.com

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    Hi Thom,
    The TV Show you just talked about was almost the same as an experiment that was done, if memory serves, at Wayne State University some decades ago. It differs in that there was no audience and an 'authority figure' came in and asked the giver of the electric shock to continue.
    the results of that experiment found that people in the USA were more likley to blindly follow authority and do what the Nazi's had done.

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    MEDICARE for ALL is a JOBS BILL --
    MEDICARE for ALL is an ECONOMIC STIMULUS BILL --

    imagine the liberty of employers recruiting great workers --
    freed of the need to secure them a lifetime of healthcare benefits --
    and the great workers free to choose their employer --

    those employees are also freed to hire --
    their emplyees freed to hire --
    etc

    thank-you for your consideration --
    GRATEFULLY EVERYTHING CHANGES --
    with so many options -- MM

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    So what was the reason given for shocking these subjects on the show anyway? We're they supposed to be known criminals, low-life scum... Bush Administration officials?

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    Thom!

    We are trying to pass the Hartmann Medicare Part E.

    Please give out these two instructions!

    1. Call your member of Congress now, and ask him or her to cosponsor HR 4789, the Public Option Act.

    Call the switchboard: (202) 224-3121

    2. After you call, please let me know how it went at WeWantMedicare.com.

    I need to know if your Representative is with us or against us. Tell me how it goes.

    This is the week to act. We are likely to vote on a healthcare bill without a public option. We should get a vote on the Public Option Act as well. The four-page bill opens Medicare to all. It's that simple.

    72 hours. 66 cosponsors in the House. 21,254 citizen cosponsors at

    The Public Option Act. It's simple. It's popular. 82% of Scott Brown voters favor it. It lets anyone buy into Medicare at cost. You want it, you pay for it, and you're in.

    Courage,

    Alan

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    No Thom, I think you had it right the first time, Dan Gainor is Darth Vader. Cheers.

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    Geeky science,

    Thom, yesterday you referenced the Watson-Crick experiment, I believe you meant the Miller-Urey experiment. http://www.chem.duke.edu/~jds/cruise_chem/Exobiolodgy/miller.html

    Taking nothing away from Messers. Watson and Crick, who first showed the double helix structure of DNA.

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    Thom’s complaint that the new Texas curriculum standards leaves out Thomas Jefferson and refers to the country as a “constitutional republic” was just the tip of the Texas-size iceberg. The input and imprint of the “Christian” and “ultra” conservative bloc—inside and outside the Texas State Board of Education deliberations room—was evident everywhere. While some educators have had the gonads to note that the English and science curriculum are now infected with right-wing politics, it was the social studies portion that has created the greatest controversy. The hostile environment was such that Democrats—outnumbered 10-5—simply walked out of those proceedings at one point. It wasn’t just “enlightened” ideas that were nixed, or the “Christian ethic” emphasized, but a wholesale removal of references to non-Caucasians. So-called multicultural figures—a euphemism for minorities—were apparently deemed “un-American.” Efforts to include even one Hispanic of historical note by name were ignored (including Cesar Chavez, despite the pleading of one elderly man during a public hearing), and the expulsion of major civil rights figures was another “victory” for conservative extremists seeking to whitewash history.

    One of the few “victories” the Democrats on the board scored was embarrassing enough Republicans to vote against a transparently racist attack against the civil rights movement, declaring that it promoted an "unrealistic expectations for equal outcomes." Nevertheless, students armed with the new texts will no longer be required to discuss the effects of institutional racism in this country. One right-wing board member had complained that the current standards falsely suggested that it was often people from racial, ethnic, and religious groups who promoted the extension of political rights in America. “Only majorities can expand political rights in America’s constitutional society,” he fulminated. In other words, minorities can march against discrimination all they want, but only the white majority has the “right” to recognize their complaints and act on them, if they so choose. We have seen this concept in action in California and Washington, both “blue states” that passed anti-affirmative action referendums.

    The new Texas history curriculum also attempts wholesale revisionism to resuscitate the images of formerly discredited right-wing figures like Joe McCarthy, and justifying the indiscriminate use of blacklisting. This is all just a part of the right’s attempt to rewrite and control history. The right has often been portrayed as the part of the ideological spectrum that has promoted race hatred, intolerance and jingoism—and rightly so; now is their chance to “correct” this “imbalance” by polluting young minds with those ideas in the guise of “learning.” It is as if modern day Nazis tried to rewrite history to put themselves back on the “right” side. The right has often and loudly complained that government and ideology has no place in school books; but since the state and not school districts purchase school texts, the curriculum is clearly tailored to appease the right-wing element that has controlled the state for decades. That element includes unapologetic creationists like Texas school board chair Don McElroy and board member Cynthia Dunbar, the latter who stated that “The philosophy of the classroom in one generation will be the philosophy of the government in the next."

    Interestingly, the right-wing element supported the inclusion of Margaret Sanger in the text; Sanger is usually hailed as a feminist hero for her “pioneering” work on birth-control. The reason why she was being promoted by the extremists on the board’s right is the same reason why I think she is no “hero”: she is to be included because she “and her followers promoted eugenics,” according to McElroy. It is a fact that Sanger regarded minorities and the poor as “inferior,” and the thrust of her work was to control the population of these “inferior” people.

    The curriculum board has thus not only infected the process with extreme politics, but with extreme arrogance—and ignorance. One right-wing board member stated that she was a proud Texan, and thought that Texas was superior to all other states, and Texas A&M professor James Kracht has stated unapologetically, “Texas governs 46 or 47 states.” Thus tens of millions of students will be taught that global warming should not only be questioned, but they will be prodded to inquire into the “implications” of being led astray by scientists. Whatever happens is “God’s will,” and there is no point in doing anything about it—or vote for Republicans so they can do nothing for you. Many people decry the state of education today; the pompous Texas education board has if anything made it worse, by undercutting critical thinking and recognition of vital issues at every turn. Education is supposed to expand the mind, not contract it.

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    Erin Go Braugh

  • Daily Topics - Wednesday - March 17th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    Happy St. Patrick's Day everybody

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday March 16th 2010   15 years 8 weeks ago

    I have always been concerned about home schooling. There is no accountability nor curriculum. In Texas: 1) there is no education requirement on the teacher 2) can operate as a private school 3) no forms or paperwork of any kind is required to be filed, although there must be a written curriculum 4) No tests or assessments are required

    I have seen a case where an "illegal Canadian" did not send her 12 year old kid to school for ~2 years. When discovered she claimed that she was "home schooling" the kid. It was a complete lie, but since the laws are so loose there was no problem.

    I am sure there are many good outcomes for home schooling, but I dare say that there many that are bad. Of course we don't have the data to know.

  • Highlights on the Show...March 15 - 19, 201   15 years 9 weeks ago

    Moveon.org folded . I think it's just the WH or someone else with the domain name. NOt sure about that, but I remember the letter on the page saying it was folding because it was too time consuming.

  • Highlights on the Show...March 15 - 19, 201   15 years 9 weeks ago

    I have a few questions.

    If corporations are people then can I deduct my health care costs as maintenance costs ?

    If corporations are people can I deduct all my living expenses like corporations deduct their costs of doing business? Like food and gas are things I need to run my overhead.

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday March 16th 2010   15 years 9 weeks ago

    Meanwhile, in an alternative universe, Mitt Romney wins in Nov'08 and pursues the exact same policies as Obama, to universal acclaim:

    http://daggatt.blogspot.com/2010/03/president-romneys-first-year.html

    (Truly a worthwhile read!)

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday March 16th 2010   15 years 9 weeks ago

    @gerald. I like children, as long as they're well done.

    "Humans...the other white meat" - bumper sticker seen on a UFO

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday March 16th 2010   15 years 9 weeks ago

    Nels,

    No, I didn't mean that progressives shouldn't do just because so-called conservatives do it. I just was observing that they actually were using a variation of that good idea of yours. ;-)

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday March 16th 2010   15 years 9 weeks ago

    Children are a great asset and resource for our country.

    Here are two educational concerns.
    1. children need to be challenged by fostering their inquisitiveness and their wonder of the world.
    2. children cannot be taught to the test. Their creativeness needs a challenged so they can discern answers to problems and questions.

    Children are not programmed robots that the religious right want to create. Not all the children should goose-step in a like manner. We must bring out their creativity.

    People who still profess that the world was built in six days are numbnuts.

    There is a Hebrew word (I cannot remember it) that means a period in time.
    In God's supernatural world there is no such concepts of time and space. God has His own time. A day may mean one trillion years as a period in time. God may have worked for six trillion ears and He rested for one trillion years before He commenced with the idea of "made to His same image and likeness" is revealed to us by the birth of His son who died for our sins. God needed to rest so He would be able to evolve ideas about His creation of the universe. It is my undestanding that planet, Earth is 4.5 billion years old.

    According to John Paul II there is a place for both creation and evolution.

    The religious right is not only doing great damage to our children but their methods are similar to child abuse.

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday March 16th 2010   15 years 9 weeks ago

    I don't say we didn't evolved from Monkeys, Apes actually, I just say people should stop sticking Darwin with that one

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday March 16th 2010   15 years 9 weeks ago

    @glenn, yes after all, whose to say monkeys didn't evolve from humans. I guess I could propose that theory.

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday March 16th 2010   15 years 9 weeks ago

    Darwin never said anything about Humans coming from Monkeys, so the Christians can knock that off, thank you.

  • Daily Topics - Tuesday March 16th 2010   15 years 9 weeks ago

    @Quark, OK conservatives have already have what I suggested... is that reason not to do it? I don't think so. Besides, I'm not looking for a corporate sponsored naval gazing exercise that the CPAC does, I'm asking for local progressive groups to put together small rally's for to bring out the local progressives and introduce them to the local progressive candidates. Whether they're running for a House Seat, State legislature seat, City Mayor, City Council, Dog Catcher etc...

ADHD: Hunter in a Farmer's World

Thom Hartmann has written a dozen books covering ADD / ADHD - Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder.

Join Thom for his new twice-weekly email newsletters on ADHD, whether it affects you or a member of your family.

Thom's Blog Is On the Move

Hello All

Thom's blog in this space and moving to a new home.

Please follow us across to hartmannreport.com - this will be the only place going forward to read Thom's blog posts and articles.